Remember me
▼ Content

Restoring Alkalinity to the Ocean



Page 27 of 28<<<25262728>
16-09-2026 18:39
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
THE MOST RELEVANT POSTS OF THIS THREAD ARE ALL COMPILED, beginning three posts down from the top of PAGE 26 (previous page)

sealover wrote:
IBdaMann wrote:
[quote]sealover wrote:Three different approaches are offered to engineer coastal wetlands to increase their output of alkalinity to neutralize ocean acidification.

sealover, the ocean has never acidified.

You would do well to learn chemistry and other basic science.

Ocean Acidification Debunked

Into the Night's comments

Coral Bleaching Debunked


"Water itself is a buffer for acid. This means the pH of the ocean water isn't going to change to any detectable degree even with the carbolic acid in it. It has the entire ocean itself acting as a buffer."

from: "Into the Night's comments" (blue link at top of post)

I have already done quite well at learning chemistry and other basic science.

Many other chemists, literally thousands, cite my published chemistry research.

I FINALLY looked at these links, after two years.

the "Into the Night's comments" were quite revealing.

NO WONDER he gave such an ignorant reply to the perfectly correct claim that one drop of acid added to pure water will cause a very large decrease in pH.

From the omniscience of a self identified "chemist" known here as Into the Night

"A very small amount of CO2 in water (around 1%) will form carbolic acid."

THIS CLAIM IS ABSURD!

Carbolic acid, aka "phenol" "phenolic acid" or "benzenol", does NOT form from carbon dioxide combining with water.

Carbolic acid, chemical formula C6H5OH, has NOTHING to do with sea water or carbon dioxide.


"Water itself is a buffer for acid. This means the pH of the ocean isn't going to change to any detectable degree even with the carbolic acid in it."

THIS CLAIM IS ABSURD!

The buffering capacity of sea water arises from the presence of oxyanions of weak acids, with bicarbonate ions and carbonate ions providing the overwhelming majority of the ocean's alkalinity (aka acid neutralizing capacity).

The absurd claim that water is a buffer for ANY acid, and the assertion that it is CARBOLIC acid forming from carbon dioxide, confirms the DISGUSTING DISHONESTY of the final words from "Into the Night's comments"

"These idiots aren't even chemists. I am... among other things."

What an effing LIAR! A "chemist" who says "water is a buffer" for "carbolic acid" formed when carbon dioxide dissolves in sea water.

Liars disgust me.

Did I forget to mention that Into the Night is a disgusting LIAR?

Lies about being a chemist. Disgusting.

"Go and learn some science" was the first thing he ever said to me.

"You obviously don't know anything about chemistry."

Says the guy who tells us

"Water itself is a buffer for acid. This means the pH of the ocean water isn't going to change any detectable degree even with the carbolic acid in it. It has the entire ocean itself acting as a buffer."
- Into the Night (aka Parrot Boy)
Edited on 16-09-2026 18:42
16-09-2026 18:56
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
CONTINUING THE COMPILILATION OF MOST RELEVANT POSTS OF THREAD, compilation begins three posts down from top of page 26 (previous page)

"..but I thought he used alcohol, and that is why we have Listerine, but I see that he used phenol, not alcohol, to sterilize." - IBdaMann

He DID use alcohol. Phenols are a subset of alcohols. All phenols are alcohols, but not all alcohols are phenols. Something you or your second rate sidekick would have learned if you ever studied chemistry.

Or you had multiple opportunities more recently to learn this, as it came up repeatedly in the ridiculous "lignin is a carbohydrate" thing.

Phenols are aromatic alcohols. All other alcohols are aliphatic alcohols.

And no word game can transform the chemistry of lignin to make it possible to classify it as a carbohydrate.

Physical properties of carbonic acid versus dissolved carbon dioxide:

Less than 1% of the CO2 that dissolves in water forms a covalent bond to water molecules to become something quite different - carbonic acid.

The more than 99% of dissolved CO2 that remains as CO2 is free to evaporate as a natural gas at ambient temperature.

However, the rate at which CO2 goes from the sea into the atmosphere is slower than the rate at which CO2 goes from the atmosphere into the sea.

The sea is a net "sink" for atmospheric carbon dioxide.

Dissolved carbon dioxide is not what makes the pH of natural rainfall about 5.6, slightly acidic. It is the less than 1% of dissolved carbon dioxide transformed into carbonic acid that supplies the protons in solution.

Unlike carbon dioxide, carbonic acid is not a gas. It is very difficult to get it into the vapor phase at ambient temperature. The sea would have to boil.

Evaporation does NOT neutralize any acid.

"The limitless ocean water keeps the average ocean pH exactly where it is."

Less than 1% of the ocean's alkalinity (i.e. pH buffering capacity) comes from its water content. The tiny fraction of water molecules that dissociate to release hydroxide into solution is negligible compared to the other buffers present. The other 99+% comes from oxyanions of weak acids, mainly bicarbonate ions and some from carbonate ions. (can't wait to see Into the Night say "bicarbonate is not a chemical" again, as if that meant something relevant to ANY discussion)

Back to the one drop of acid in one liter of pure water, which IBdaMann and Into the Night both agree is well buffered against significant pH change.

Regardless of the concentration of acid used to make the one drop, the pH of the pure water WILL decrease.

If you add that drop of acid to 100 liters of pure water, the pH will still drop, but not as much. That one drop of acid in a MILLION liters of pure water will lower the pH, but maybe not enough to measure the difference.

But the "limitless" ocean water is up against a "limitless" atmosphere. It isn't just one drop of acid being added.

And the 0.0000001 moles per liter of hydroxide ion in pure water is so tiny it makes pure water the LEAST buffered wet stuff you can find.

And I'm only bothering to respond to IBdaMann because I want to see Parrot Boy triple down and insist that carbon dioxide DOES form carbolic acid in water.

And then claim to have knowledge of chemistry far superior to my own.

PARROT POOP FOREVER!


IBdaMann wrote:
Im a BM wrote: Let's see... I first learned about carbolic acid when I was in sixth grade.

I'm not well read on phenol. I like dopamine, seratonin and endorphins, though.

Im a BM wrote: I was reading a book about the history of medical science.

There was an old sketch from the Pasteur era, when doctors had finally figured out that disease can be spread by microscopic germs. Germs which could be killed with certain chemicals.

The sketch was of a doctor spraying a solution of carbolic acid over the open wound during surgery.

I remember reading that as well. It was Joseph Lister who did that, but I thought he used alcohol, and that is why we have Listerine, but I see that he used phenol, not alcohol to sterilize. Interesting.

Im a BM wrote: Carbonic acid is a very poor disinfectant, at best.

I had already learned, in sixth grade, that it was CARBONIC acid that formed from carbon dioxide.

I also learned what happens when that acidic solution evaporates, i.e. it's a CO2 cycle. CO2 in the atmosphere gets into precipitation making carbonic acid, evaporates and returns to the atmosphere.

Im a BM wrote: Did you read Into the Night's post?

I'm far more familiar with my own posts; I know what I mean when I write something. Into the Night and I use different terms on many topics, which is why you have to address content. If a particular term doesn't sit right with you, you should specifically discuss it.

I'll tell you that you are making an error if you think that whatever terms you learned are somehow universal. I learned the hard way that what I thought are standard science and math terms are almost always expressed differently by engineers, government workers and industry specialists. If you are getting hung up on a word/term, that's fine, but discuss it first. I'm looking for validity, and then soundness, of arguments.

Im a BM wrote:Aren't you even curious to know what he thinks he's writing about?

I might be curious if he were making an argument. He's not. He's explaining to you why he doesn't accept your affirmative argument, which isn't an argument so much as it is an unsupported conclusion.

Let's review momentarily. You insist that:

1. The ocean is losing its alkalinity.
2. Earth's average equilibrium temperature is rising.
3. Climate Change is making the world worse.

These are the conclusions that you are supposed to be supporting with your arguments, but you are not.

You are, instead, making the case that Into the Night was mistaken about something. Let's say, hypothetically, that you are successful and you triumph. Which of the three conclusions above will you be supporting?


Im a BM wrote: Perhaps he will tell us again that "carbolic acid is not carbonic acid".

When he correctly does, where will that leave us?

Im a BM wrote: What possible mechanism would allow water molecules to prevent the pH from changing when acid is added?

It doesn't have to prevent; it has to resist. Huge water quantities do this as well. If you need the resistance to be independent of quantity then that's fine also, but you should specify this, otherwise the limitless ocean water keeps the average ocean pH exactly where it is.

Edited on 16-09-2026 18:58
16-09-2026 19:01
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Im a BM wrote:
"I started reading through this but I had to stop." - IBdaMann

This is regarding the paper that IBdaMann brought to our attention.

An excellent paper, among the first to say much about organic alkalinity.

IBdaMann originally claimed that this paper included the term "alkaline neutralizing capacity", and served as proof that I was wrong.

Too bad he was too scientifically illiterate to understand the "gibber babble".

Too bad he failed in his attempt to understand the paper he brought in.

He could have learned what the term "organic" means to chemists.

A year and a half later, he still doesn't have a clue.

He could have learned what alkalinity is. A year and a half later, he still thinks that buffering just means acid gets diluted in water, because "water itself is a buffer."

Still doesn't have a clue about how bicarbonate ions and carbonate ions provide 99% of the sea's buffering capacity, or how increasing concentration of carbonic acid decreases concentration of carbonate ions.

I guess he couldn't do it without someone there to spoon feed him definitions for all those big words he never learned because he never actually studied any science.

Once a troll, always a troll.



IBdaMann wrote:
Im a BM wrote:Acid Neutralizing Capacity, Alkalinity, and Acid-Base Status of Natural Waters Containing Organic Acids

I started reading through this but I had to stop. I'll get back to it later today. In the meantime, I was hoping you would explain something that is giving me a bad taste about this article. What does the author mean by "organic." The article uses the word "organic" more liberally than products at Walmart. As you know, carbon is an element and can't be organic, yet you have used the term, as does this article "organic carbon" like that is supposed to mean something important, just not important enough to explain it to those reading the article. Then it uses the term "organic acids" without explaining. At Costco they sell "organic" chocolate milk without explaining that either. Should I be ignoring this article or is there really something I, as the reader, need to know that the stupid author was too brain-dead to mention?

How am I, as the reader, expected to understand the word "organic" in this article? I know of many meanings, but the one that I would expect from a chemist is "carbon-based" or "of life/living/alive" ... and not this silly, seemingly redundant "organic carbon" crap. Anyway, I wouldn't care one way or the other if the author would explain up front instead of presuming that his readers are all mind-readers.

Im a BM wrote:The terms acid neutralizing capacity (ANC) and alkalinity (Alk) are extensively employed in the characterization of natural waters, including soft circumneutral oracidic waters.

I'm looking forward to reading all about it. Will the author be explaining these terms or am I expected to wonder what kind of waters are synthetic waters? ... and whether or not there are oralkaline waters and what that even means? Will the paper also discuss circumacidic waters and circumbasic waters ... or only the circumneutral waters?

Im a BM wrote:It DOES give good background on "The terms acid neutralizing capacity (ANC) and alkalinity (Alk)..." Recommended reading for those who have difficulty with these definitions.

I'm looking forward to reading all about it.

Im a BM wrote:But what is special about the paper is recognition that organic alkalinity is a not a negligible contributor to total alkalinity. Indeed, our understanding of alkalinity is incomplete without it.

What do chemists consider "substantive" in this case?

Im a BM wrote:Organic alkalinity is responsible for making iron available to support photosynthesis in the sea.

Seawater gets its iron from other sources; the alkalinity is incidental. Thermal vents, erosion, dust, etc. all bring iron into the ocean.



"How am I, as the reader, expected to understand the word 'organic' in this article?"

"Then it uses the term 'organic acids' without explaining."

"...and not this silly, seemingly redundant, 'organic carbon' crap."

"...presuming that his readers are all mind readers."


You, as the reader, are expected to be scientifically literate enough to understand the word "organic" in this article.

The term "organic acids" is so common, with 150 years of usage among scientists, that no research article needs to repeat the definition again.

The "'organic carbon' crap" is what you will find in chemistry research articles.

Readers of peer-reviewed scientific articles are not expected to be mind readers.

Readers ARE presumed to be scientifically literate enough to understand BASIC terms like "organic", "organic carbon", "organic acid", and even "organic alkalinity".

Referring to the "stupid author" as being the legitimate object of grievance because he failed to spoon feed remedial education for the potential reader who never studied enough chemistry to get anything out of the article anyway...

No, the failure here is the arrogance of the READER.

But, isn't IBdaMann omniscient about all things scientific?

Shouldn't he be explaining to the author what the words REALLY mean?

Maybe he will get a Nobel Prize for proving that there is no such thing as organic carbon.
16-09-2026 19:03
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
IBdaMann wrote:
sealover wrote: one more attempt to attach a file
Let's see if it let me attach the pdf file


I'll attach the abstract. The parts in red are just boolsch't. The underlined phrases are the calls for greater funding and greater government control while downplaying any need to provide specifics.

Submarine groundwater discharge (SGD) links terrestrial and marine systems, but has often been overlooked in coastal nutrient budgets because it is difficult to quantify. In this Review, we examine SGD nutrient fluxes in over 200 locations globally, explain their impact on biogeochemistry and discuss broader management implications. SGD nutrient fluxes exceed river inputs in ~60% of study sites, with median total SGD fluxes of 6.0 mmol m−2 per day for dissolved inorganic nitrogen, 0.1 mmol m−2 per day for dissolved inorganic phosphorus and 6.5 mmol m−2 per day for dissolved silicate. SGD nitrogen input (mostly in the form of ammonium and dissolved organic nitrogen) often mitigates nitrogen limitation in coastal waters, since SGD tends to have high nitrogen concentrations relative to phosphorus (76% of studies showed N
values above the Redfield ratio
). It is notable that most investigations do not distinguish saline and fresh SGD, although they have different properties. Saline SGD is a ubiquitous, diffuse pathway releasing mostly recycled nutrients to global coastal waters, whereas fresh SGD is occasionally a local, point source of new nutrients. SGD-derived nutrient fluxes must be considered in water quality management plans, as these inputs can promote eutrophication if not properly managed.


A casual glance will reveal that this document is intended to say absolutely nothing while filling the mandatory quota of white space with text. The thesis statement, i.e. that greater funding and control are required in this area, is pushed by fear, of course. This document seeks to engender a panic surrounding the flourishing of plants and algaes that might happen if this funding and control are not increased per this alarm warning. Did you catch that? The threat is possible "eutrophication", i.e. that plants and algaes might flourish.

sealover, the first line of the abstract says that SGD links terrestrial and marine systems. Does that mean that SGD links Army tactical vehicles to Navy aircraft carriers? ... or does it link terrestrial data centers with ocean drilling platforms?



So, why wasn't the term "dissolved organic nitrogen" highlighted in RED?

More than a year after IBdaMann posted this, he realized that there is NO SUCH THING as "organic carbon" or "organic nitrogen".

Yet, the abstract he posted was from an article that was among the first to show how much dissolved organic nitrogen is contained in submarine groundwater discharge.

Dissolved organic nitrogen is very real and very important.

Yes, this was one of the first responses to my very first post.

It begins with an unsourced cut and paste abstract of perfectly valid science.

This is followed by bizarre anti scientific analysis.

"This document seeks to engender panic.."

The "scientific" analysis is purely political, if not simply delusional.

However, the abstract contains something the fills me with pride.

It mentions that "..ammonium and dissolved organic nitrogen.." were the main forms of nitrogen in submarine groundwater discharge.

A search of scientific papers reveals that prior to 1995, the term "dissolved organic nitrogen" appears in the title of just three papers.

One of them was my own, "Determination of dissolved organic nitrogen using persulfate oxidation..." (1994, Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis).

We developed a new method to measure dissolved organic nitrogen because the classic Kjeldahl digest was too cumbersome, slow, dangerous, and inaccurate.

But dissolved organic nitrogen didn't really get much attention until after 1995.

That was the year I published the paper in the journal Nature.

The first sentence was:

"The importance of dissolved organic nitrogen (DON) in ecosystem nutrient fluxes and plant nutrition is only beginning to be appreciated."

The same issue of Nature (1995) includes a review article about the significance of my paper:

"New cog in the nitrogen cycle". (easy to look up with just those words)

Before that, virtually nobody was even trying to measure dissolved organic nitrogen in waters (soil water, ground water, surface water)

They knew that it existed as a theoretical component, but assumed it was negligible.

It is now standard fare to include measure of dissolved organic nitrogen, in addition to nitrate, ammonium, and sometimes nitrite, in water samples.

Otherwise they miss what is often a major component of the total nitrogen.

So, I am very proud of this contribution I made to real world science.

Persulfate oxidation has also now largely replaced the Kjeldahl digest to measure organic nitrogen. Something else I am proud of.

But I am MOST proud that OTHER discoveries I published are frequently cited in newer work related to climate change.

For example, the importance of plant polyphenols (tannins) for sequestration of carbon into stable organic matter with very long mean residence time in soil.

For example, the importance of plant polyphenols for minimizing the emission of nitrous oxide, a very powerful greenhouse gas.

For example, the importance of plant mycorrhizal associations for facilitating the sequestration of carbon and minimizing nitrous oxide emissions.

On the other hand, having published those widely cited papers, I can allow them to speak for themselves. Those who have cited me in their own papers can elaborate on the significance without my help.

Meanwhile, my research into the biogeochemistry of coastal wetland groundwater in the Sacramento-San Joaquin delta is all about the SOURCE of submarine groundwater discharge. That data is NOT available in any scientific journals.

Unfortunately, the abstract that IBdaMann cut and pasted did NOT reference data for ALKALINITY in submarine groundwater discharge - the thread topic.
16-09-2026 19:05
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Im a BM wrote:
IBdaMann wrote:
[quote].

[quote]Environ. Sci. Technol.1990,24,1486-1489
Acid Neutralizing Capacity, Alkalinity, and Acid-Base Status of Natural Waters Containing Organic Acids

Harold F. Hemond
Water Resources and Environmental Engineering, Department of Civil Engineering, and Massachusetts Institute of Technology Energy Laboratory, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139

Downloaded by MIT on October 2, 2009 [url]http://pubs.acs.orgPublicationDate
ctober1,1990|doi:10.1021/es00080a005[/url]

The terms acid neutralizing capacity (ANC) and alkalinity (Alk) are extensively employed in the characterization of natural waters, including soft circumneutral oracidic waters. However, in the presence of organic acids, ANC measurements are inconsistent with many conceptual definitions of ANC or Alk and do not provide an adequate characterization of the acid-base chemistry of water.





I have actually referenced this paper before in communications about organic alkalinity.

For years, the importance of organic acid anions as contributors to alkalinity was overlooked.

In the case of submarine groundwater discharge, these organic anions (deprotonated organic acids) can be 25% of total alkalinity.

This paper points out that organic acids need to be taken into account for more accurate understanding of alkalinity.

Since 2009, a lot of progress has been made in this area. The term "organic alkalinity" or ALKorg is now widely used and, more importantly, is now being measured directly in order to fill in the gaps.

I'm pretty sure that Harold and Hemond never once said anything about "alkaline neutralizing capacity" or "alkalinity neutralizing capacity".

They are scientists. They weren't just playing word games.

I've already cited their work, anyway.

If anyone wants to PM me, I could send you a bibliography about the subject, including the Harold and Hemond (2009) paper.



Organic Alkalinity and Potential Significance for Ocean "Acidification"

IBdaMann found an excellent research paper and posted it.

The most important contribution of this paper was to point out that organic alkalinity is an overlooked contributor to total alkalinity.

Kind of reminds me how what most scientists called the most important contribution of my 1995 paper in NATURE was to point out that organic nitrogen is an overlooked contributor to total nitrogen.

Organic acids tend to be weak acids. That makes them good buffers.

Citric acid, for example, only partially deprotonates at near neutral pH.

Some of it remains present as citric acid, with proton still attached.

Some of it deprotonates, dissociating into hydrogen cation (H+) and citrate anion.

Citrate buffers work best in the slightly acidic range, as they can neutralize a proton by protonating a citrate anion to form citric acid which remains protonated. Or some of the citric acid can deprotonate into citrate anion, and that proton can neutralize any added base (OH-).

But the buffering capacity of organic alkalinity doesn't offer much help with regard to ocean "acidification". Organic alkalinity is only the tiniest fraction of the sea's total alkalinity, way below 1%.

On the other hand, organic alkalinity can comprise 25% of total alkalinity in groundwater of some wetlands, according to colleagues of mine.

Most places it is a lot less than that, but it is still a contributor in the alkalinity of submarine groundwater discharge from coastal wetlands.

But the most relevant feature of organic alkalinity with regard to ocean acidification is the metal-complexing capacity of organic anions.

There would not be enough iron in seawater to support photosynthesis without metal complexing organic anions chelating iron to keep it soluble.

Without enough iron to support photosynthesis, inorganic carbon dissolved in sea water would not get transformed into organic carbon, neutralizing ocean acidification.

So, organic alkalinity is actually very important.
16-09-2026 19:13
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
IBdaMann wrote:
sealover wrote:Correct. I only use the term "ocean acidification" because that is what is popularly understood.

You are a liar.

You came to this site to preach non-science gibber-babble. You attempted to post a document full of meaningless technical jargon, not one that attempts to explain anything clearly to laymen.

sealover wrote:It is the depletion of alkalinity, not acidification.

Chemistry is not your strength. You should give up pretending it is. You aren't going to find many on this site who will fall for your crap.


sealover wrote:I did study chemistry and other basic science, including a master's degree from UC Berkeley and a PhD from UC Davis.

You do not have a degree in Chemistry. That much is painfully obvious.

However, having an affiliation with UC Davis speaks volumes about how much science you were obligated to ignore.


sealover wrote:Two of my publications, in the journals Nature and Biogeochemistry, got a whole lot of attention from climate change investigators.

Translation: "I wrote crap that appealed to scientifically illiterate leftist political hacktivists at local ANTIFA, BLM and Communist Party chapters!"

sealover wrote:I don't expect any particular level of respect based solely on my credentials.

You were expecting respect based solely on the sheer incomprehensibility of your gibber-babble.

Ocean Acidification Debunked

Into the Night's comments

Coral Bleaching Debunked

Forget about posting gibberish papers.

Just explain your point in your own words.



I love the way IBdaMann explains his point in his own words in the "Ocean Acidification Debunked" (blue highlighted) link.

He explains how "Life is acidic" and how "Alkaline environments are hostile to life and require special adaptations in order to survive". Furthermore, "If the ocean's pH level were to decrease and to cross the threshold to become acidic, marine life would thrive as never before".

And Into the Night explains his point in his own words in "Into the Night's comments" (blue highlighted) link.

Into the Night explains how the "carbolic acid" formed from some of the carbon dioxide dissolved in sea water has any pH acidifying effect neutralized by dilution because "water itself is a buffer for acid"

This post by IBdaMann was within hours of my very first post at this website.
16-09-2026 19:18
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Imagine a coastline where the rising sea level is creeping up into the saltwater wetlands. Little by little, the estuary is being submerged. In a few decades it will be completely underwater.

When the sea level was lower, the low tide was at an elevation well below the estuary soil surface. There was a steep hydraulic gradient to drain water out for a little while. This enabled sulfate rich sea water to move through the organic carbon rich, low oxygen wetland sediment. In so doing, sulfate reducing bacteria were supplied with the substrate they needed to use as a terminal electron acceptor to oxidize organic carbon to acquire metabolic energy. As the estuary water drained out at low tide, it carried with it the alkalinity (carbonate and bicarbonate ions) generated during sulfate reduction.

Now that the sea level is higher, the low tide isn't as low anymore. There is less elevation difference between low tide and land surface. Less of a hydraulic gradient to drive sea water through the sediments. Less sulfate reduction and less alkalinity provided to the ocean.

Now picture a simple wind turbine or sea wave powered pump off the edge of the estuary. It is pumping sea water a meter or two uphill into the estuary at low tide. There is now more hydraulic pressure to push sea water through the sediments and bring about sulfate reduction and alkalinity generation. The reservoir of organic carbon is already there, lacking only a sufficient hydraulic gradient to get sea water to pass through it.

It might be enough to have a pipe transport the sea water from the pump up on to the estuary a hundred meters back from the edge. More sulfate reduction and alkalinity generation could be facilitated if a berm is constructed of sediment along the edge of the estuary to delay the lateral flow of water off the surface back to sea at low tide.

Even without actively pumping any sea water, a berm alone could accomplish much of the same objective. If the top of the berm is lower than the high tide, it can fill up with sea water. When the tide goes back down, the berm will hold back the water to keep it on the estuary a while longer. Infiltrating sea water into the sediments rather than flowing off the surface back out to sea.

We could assist the estuary to do again what it used to do so well before the sea level got so high. Supplying alkalinity to marine ecosystems.
16-09-2026 19:21
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Power Assisted Estuaries

Imagine a coastline where the rising sea level is creeping up into the saltwater wetlands. Little by little, the estuary is being submerged. In a few decades it will be completely underwater.

When the sea level was lower, the low tide was at an elevation well below the estuary soil surface. There was a steep hydraulic gradient to drain water out for a little while. This enabled sulfate rich sea water to move through the organic carbon rich, low oxygen wetland sediment. In so doing, sulfate reducing bacteria were supplied with the substrate they needed to use as a terminal electron acceptor to oxidize organic carbon to acquire metabolic energy. As the estuary water drained out at low tide, it carried with it the alkalinity (carbonate and bicarbonate ions) generated during sulfate reduction.

Now that the sea level is higher, the low tide isn't as low anymore. There is less elevation difference between low tide and land surface. Less of a hydraulic gradient to drive sea water through the sediments. Less sulfate reduction and less alkalinity provided to the ocean.

Now picture a simple wind turbine or sea wave powered pump off the edge of the estuary. It is pumping sea water a meter or two uphill into the estuary at low tide. There is now more hydraulic pressure to push sea water through the sediments and bring about sulfate reduction and alkalinity generation. The reservoir of organic carbon is already there, lacking only a sufficient hydraulic gradient to get sea water to pass through it.

It might be enough to have a pipe transport the sea water from the pump up on to the estuary a hundred meters back from the edge. More sulfate reduction and alkalinity generation could be facilitated if a berm is constructed of sediment along the edge of the estuary to delay the lateral flow of water off the surface back to sea at low tide.

Even without actively pumping any sea water, a berm alone could accomplish much of the same objective. If the top of the berm is lower than the high tide, it can fill up with sea water. When the tide goes back down, the berm will hold back the water to keep it on the estuary a while longer. Infiltrating sea water into the sediments rather than flowing off the surface back out to sea.

We could assist the estuary to do again what it used to do so well before the sea level got so high. Supplying alkalinity to marine ecosystems.
16-09-2026 19:25
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Im a BM wrote:
Into the Night wrote:
Im a BM wrote:
"It is not possible for pH to be less than 1" - Into the Night

You heard it here first, everyone! NOT possible for pH to be less than 1...

For reasons unexplained, MOST pH scales display the range from 0-14.

Does ANYONE believe Into the Night got better than a "C" in high school chemistry?

Into the Night wrote:
Im a BM wrote:
Proof that even GOOGLE is a more competent "chemist" than Into the Night.

Ask Google the following question:

"What is the pH of a 1.0 M (molar) solution of hydrochloric acid?"

Google's answer is unambiguous and succinct.

Google says: "The pH of a 1.0 M solution of hydrochloric acid is 0."

Google = smart.
Into the Night = dumbass who pretends to be a "chemist".

It is not possible for pH to be less than 1.
Chemistry is not a website or search engine.
Attempted proof by void.

I already know you have no understanding of pH. You don't have to keep proving it.


So, are you now digging in and standing by your assertion that "It is not possible for pH to be less than 1"?

Who could ever have any doubt that you really ARE a "chemist"?


Science is not Google. Google is not a chemical. Google probably isn't God. I am not Google. Google isn't even a "chemistry", but it provides information about chemistry that tends to be very accurate.

Question for Google:

"Is the carbonate ion a 'chemical' or a 'class' of chemicals?"

Google's answer: "The carbonate ion (CO3, 2-) is a specific POLYATOMIC ION, but 'carbonate' also refers to a broad class of compounds (salts/esters) containing that ion, making it both a SPECIFIC CHEMICAL ENTITY and a category for many substances like limestone, soda ash, and even some organic compounds (carbonates)."

A follow up question for Google:

"What do water chemists mean when they refer to 'carbonate' in solution?"

Google says: "In water chemistry, the term 'carbonate' in solution refers to the various species that exist in the equilibrium system involving carbonic acid, bicarbonate ions, and carbonate ions. These species are crucial in determining the pH, alkalinity, and buffering capacity."

Also known as "the carbonate system" or "the CaCO3 system", it regulates pH AND alkalinity (not the same as pH)

Google gets the chemistry right. Into the Night doesn't get the chemistry at all.
16-09-2026 19:28
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Into the Night wrote:
Im a BM wrote:
I could, again, show you the references and the calculations for hydrochloric acid, nitric acid, and sulfuric acid in multiple examples. Show you how far below zero pH can go.

So, remind me that "sulfuric is not a chemical" "hydrochloric is not a chemical, and "nitric is not a chemical" and you won another round in the "debate".

Nah. I've already seen your math errors. You don't need to show them to me again.


Perhaps I never explained this before.

Scientifically illiterate trolls were NEVER the "target audience" for my biogeochemistry musings.

Of course ITN isn't interested in the real world chemistry of what pH is or how it is calculated (let alone the carbonate system of pH buffering in the sea).

The term "pH" includes two symbols. The "p" stands for the negative logarithm of whatever number follows. The "H" stands for the molarity (moles per liter) of the hydrogen ion (H+ or H3O+) in solution.

The negative logarithm means you put a minus sign on whatever the calculated logarithm is. For example, a 0.1 molar solution of nitric acid has 0.1 moles per liter H+. The logarithm of 0.1 is -1. The NEGATIVE logarithm 0.1 = 1. A solution of 0.1 M nitric acid has pH =1.

Now make it a 1.0 molar solution of nitric acid. The logarithm of 1.0 = 0.
The negative logarithm of 1.0 = 0. The pH of 1.0 M nitric acid = 0.

Okay, it's easy enough to make a 2.0 M solution of nitric acid. What's the pH?
The logarithm of 2.0 = 0.301. The negative logarithm = -0.301. Therefore, the pH of a 2.0 M solution of nitric acid = -0.301. YES, it is possible.

"Alkalinity" is not a measure of pH. Alkalinity is the acid neutralizing capacity that arises from the conjugate bases of weak acids. In the ocean, that weak acid is carbonic acid, H2CO3.

CO2 + H2O = H2CO3
H2CO3 = H+ + HCO3-
HCO3- = H+ + CO3(2-)

The net flux of CO2 goes from the atmosphere into the sea, although CO2 leaves the sea to the atmosphere, but at a slower rate than it comes in.

The net flux of ACIDITY is for "carbonic acid gas" (what they used to call CO2) to enter the sea from the atmosphere. Pure water allowed to reach equilibrium with the atmosphere reaches a pH of about 5.6 due to carbonic acid formation.

But the net flux of ALKALINITY is from land to sea. Carbonate ions, CO3(2-) constantly enter the sea. These neutralize carbonic acid.

CO3(2-) + H2CO3 = 2 HCO3- the reaction produces two bicarbonate ions.

I'm sure that we can count on some heckling from the local chemistry clown troll. "Carbonate is not a chemical!" "There is no such thing as the 'carbonate system'" "It is not possible for pH to be below zero" "Water itself is a buffer for acid" "You cannot acidify an alkaline" "There is no coral bleaching" "You deny science" "You are not a chemist"

More than 99% of the sea's acid neutralizing capacity (alkalinity) arises from bicarbonate ions and carbonate ions. Carbonate ion is far more scarce than bicarbonate ion in sea water. As carbonate ions get depleted by neutralizing carbonic acid, fewer of them are available in solution for organisms to use for calcium carbonate shell formation. Due to ocean "acidification", many shellfish farms now must purchase alkaline material to add to the rookery water. Otherwise, there isn't enough carbonate available for healthy larval shell development.

The single greatest source of new carbonate ions entering the sea is the process of microbial sulfate reduction. Sulfate reducing bacteria use sulfate as terminal electron acceptor to oxidize organic carbon under low oxygen conditions. Aerobic oxidation of organic carbon produces carbon dioxide as the oxidized (inorganic) carbon product. Anaerobic oxidation of organic carbon using an oxyanion such as sulfate for terminal electron acceptor produces CARBONATE ION as the oxidized (inorganic) carbon product. Other such oxyanion terminal electron acceptors that bacteria can use to oxidize organic carbon anaerobically (generating alkalinity) include nitrate, phosphate, arsenate, borate, selenate, molybdate, and many others.

I'm sure that the temptation to troll will be irresistible. I'm not trying to hurt your feelings, but you were NEVER the target audience for my posts. You don't even believe that there IS such a thing as biogeochemistry, and you are too ignorant to realize that climate CAN and DOES change.
16-09-2026 19:34
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Into the Night wrote:
Im a BM wrote:
Robert Wagner wrote:
IBdaMann wrote:
Robert Wagner wrote:So you just learned about buffer solutions now?

... and now that I have taught you, you should know it as well. I do hope you were paying attention.




I've known about buffer solutions for over 30 years, poor delusional troll.


What was so silly that the little girl is laughing at?

Well, sealover said, "If I take a liter of pure water and add just one drop of concentrated acid, I will see a huge drop in pH."

IBdaMann responded by correcting the "mistake"

"If you were to get your hands on some magical acid whose pH is 0.0, and you were to add one single drop to one liter/litre of pure water (pH 7.0), and one single drop to one liter/litre of sea water (pH 8.4), the impact of a drop of acid would be more pronounced on the sea water than on the pure water." - IBdaMann

You ARE sealover, Robert. You're the only one with socks here.

I already know you don't any thing about acids or alkalines. You don't have to prove it.


Here's the best part. IBdaMann says "...and now that I have taught you, you should know it as well."

He plays that "See? I taught YOU!" bullshit every step of the way.

It turns out that IBdaMann taught ME that pH can go below zero. He used math and everything!

"pH = -ln(H+)" said IBdaMann. That meant that the 1.5 M nitric acid solution really DID have pH below zero.

But that was long after he insisted that an acid would have to be "magical" to have pH = 0.0, and that pure water was MORE BUFFERED than sea water to resist pH change upon addition of a drop of acid.

Since he never actually studied chemistry or used "pH" in any math applications, he didn't realize that the logarithm was BASE TEN. pH = -log(H+).

But every step of the way, when IBdaMann realized he was just wrong, he pretended that the CORRECT position had actually been his all along and HE was the one who taught it to YOU.

"So, Mr. Chemistry Genius.." (the line IBdaMann used to address me), what did you teach Robert Wagner about "buffering"?

Did you tell him about the "exponential change to basicity", the "delta(solution)" equation where the "magnitude of effect" could be calculated, and how "change to the acid" accounts for why you said pure water was so much better buffered than sea water against pH change?

Well pure water does "buffer" the acid by DILUTION, and as IBdaMann explains, the sea is "limitless" in its capacity to mitigate pollution with infinite dilution. Besides, all the carbonic acid in sea water just "evaporates", right?

So, you've got these two scientifically illiterate trolls who, literally, don't even know what pH or buffering IS.

But they sure have a LOT to say as experts in science, and they just never seem to stop trolling.

You cannot acidify an alkaline, apparently.

And it turns out that carbonate is NOT a chemical, precisely, so "carbonate" is meaningless in discussion of ocean acidification. Carbonate chemistry doesn't exist because carbonate is not a chemical, and has no chemical behavior to speak of.

I remain true to my RELIGIOUS FAITH in the firm belief that sulfate CAN be reduced, and their IS "such a thing" as the inorganic carbon product of anaerobic oxidation of organic carbon. I believe, I believe, I believe that the ocean's "carbonate system" of pH buffering is REAL. With blind faith I cling to the belief in submarine groundwater discharge as the vehicle of transport that provides most of the carbonate ions entering the sea.

I worship a false god of biogeochemistry.

Somebody needs to remind me that I am a scientifically illiterate moron.

No, worse than that. I'm deceptively advancing an EVIL agenda, fraudulently presenting myself as a "scientist", perhaps just totally gullible as a Marxist puppet, or one of the most evil of knowing conspirators...

IBdaMann and Into the Night, providing quality assurance at climate-debate.com
16-09-2026 19:35
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
DEFINE YOUR TERMS!

"Learn what 'buffering' means in chemistry." - Into the Night
"Again, you ignore the concept of buffering in chemistry." - Into the Night


Actually I drew attention to the "concept of buffering", particularly when I referred to the "sea's carbonate buffer system"

Into the Night has NEVER defined his terms for even the most "basic" concepts of pH buffering. This post was the first time I ever saw him use the term, until I was directed by IBdaMann to an old post "Into the Night's comments" in which it was explained that "water itself is a buffer for acid"

Into the Night, I know it is a LOST CAUSE to get you to reveal your SECRET definition for "pH".

What do you think you are saying when you say "buffer"?

Help me understand how "water itself is a buffer for acid"

Because where I got MY chemistry degrees, they taught us that a "buffer" is the conjugate base of a weak acid that enables an aqueous solution to resist pH change upon addition of acid.

In the ocean, one such "weak acid" is carbonic acid, H2CO3.

Its conjugate base is the bicarbonate ion, HCO3-.
H2CO3 = H+ + HCO3- the bicarbonate ion supplies about nine tenths of the ocean's alkalinity. The sea's average alkalinity is about 2.3 millimoles per liter acid neutralizing capacity, or about 115 milligrams per liter as CaCO3 equivalents.

Another even weaker acid in sea water is the bicarbonate ion, HCO3-.

HCO3- = H+ + CO3(2-) the conjugate base of the very weak acid bicarbonate ion is the CARBONATE ION, CO3(2-). The carbonate ion supplies about one tenth of the ocean's alkalinity, or pH buffering capacity.

So that's the definition of "buffer" that I was taught.

I don't get the impression you were taught ANY definition for "buffer", the concept of which you ignore.

Please share your SECRET definition of "buffer" or "buffering" so that I can understand how the heck it is that "Water itself is a buffer for acid".

quote]Into the Night wrote:
sealover wrote:
one more attempt to attach a file

The ocean absorbs more than a third of our carbon dioxide emissions.

Nope. It is not possible to measure 'our' CO2 emissions, nor the CO2 emissions of any nation. The CO2 concentrate in the ocean matches that of the air. It is not possible to measure the global CO2 concentrate of the atmosphere (or of the oceans). CO2 is not uniformly distributed in the atmosphere (or the oceans).
sealover wrote:
The ocean's alkalinity has been depleted ("acidification").

It is not possible to measure the pH of the oceans. It is not uniform.
sealover wrote:
The balance of the sea's carbonate buffer system has shifted.

There is no such thing. Learn what 'buffering' means in chemistry.
sealover wrote:
Carbonic acid is now more abundant, and carbonate ion is relatively more scarce.

More made up shit. Carbonic acid forms anywhere there is dissolved CO2 in water. Carbonic acid also forms dissolved CO2 in water. The two reactions form an equilibrium, with only a very small percentage existing as carbonic acid at any given time.
sealover wrote:
Deficiency of carbonate impedes shell formation in marine life.

No. It's CRITICAL for shellfish to exist. Carbonic acid helps to break down the limestone in the ocean floor and make it available to shellfish to form their shells.
sealover wrote:
Commercial aquaculture must now artificially add alkalinity to raise healthy stocks.

You don't have that ability. Man does not have that ability. Again, you ignore the concept of buffering in chemistry.[/quote]
16-09-2026 19:38
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Dredge Spoils, Acid Sulfate Soils!

I was surprised to discover that an invited chemistry presentation that I gave to the US Army Corps of Engineers in 2008 can be found on the Internet.

https://dots.el.erdc.dren.mil/workshops/2008-04-15-doer-20_SPK_DMAttenuation_Northup.pdf

I don't know if this will show up as an actual link, or just a website address that I typed for others to copy.

It is HIGHLY relevant to the topic of this thread.

From the title page:
"Dredged Material and Acid Sulfate Soils

Biogeochemistry of Upland Placement of Dredged Sediments on Delta Peatland Soils

Sediment pH and Attenuation of Arsenic, Copper, Nitrate Nitrogen, and Dissolved Organic Carbon (DOC)

Robert R. Northup, Ph.D.
rnorthup@nature.berkeley.edu"


My presentation was on the second day of the US Army Corps of Engineers Dredging Conference, in Sacramento, California, April 16, 2008.

Note how the US government facilitates the publication of "buzzwords" such as "biogeochemistry" and "organic carbon".

The US Army Corps of Engineers seemed to be under the impression that this PhD character knew something about "pH" and "Acid Sulfate Soils", as if I were some kind of "chemist"

I've got EVERYONE fooled except YARP (Yellow And Red Parrot) and IBdaMann.

YARP, I double dog DARE you to open this US Army Corps of Engineers document on the Internet, the address listed above, ending in "...Attenuation_Northup.pdf"

You can prove you know more about the chemistry of pyrite oxidation, for example, by explaining the chemistry of what is WRONG with my 2008 presentation to the US Army Corps of Engineers. You don't have to say what "pH" or "buffering" actually IS, just show what's wrong with MY presentation about "pH" and "Acid Sulfate Soils".

The first one is a freebie: "There is NO SUCH THING as 'acid sulfate soil'. Buzzword!" And you can list all the other "no such thing" and "buzzword" and "something is not something else" to prove that I just do not understand chemistry. And readers will benefit from your CORRECT chemistry lesson.

IBdaMann wrote:
sealover wrote:Correct. I only use the term "ocean acidification" because that is what is popularly understood.

You are a liar.

You came to this site to preach non-science gibber-babble. You attempted to post a document full of meaningless technical jargon, not one that attempts to explain anything clearly to laymen.

sealover wrote:It is the depletion of alkalinity, not acidification.

Chemistry is not your strength. You should give up pretending it is. You aren't going to find many on this site who will fall for your crap.

sealover wrote:I did study chemistry and other basic science, including a master's degree from UC Berkeley and a PhD from UC Davis.

You do not have a degree in Chemistry. That much is painfully obvious.

However, having an affiliation with UC Davis speaks volumes about how much science you were obligated to ignore.

sealover wrote:Two of my publications, in the journals Nature and Biogeochemistry, got a whole lot of attention from climate change investigators.

Translation: "I wrote crap that appealed to scientifically illiterate leftist political hacktivists at local ANTIFA, BLM and Communist Party chapters!"

sealover wrote:I don't expect any particular level of respect based solely on my credentials.

You were expecting respect based solely on the sheer incomprehensibility of your gibber-babble.

Ocean Acidification Debunked

Into the Night's comments

Coral Bleaching Debunked

Forget about posting gibberish papers.

Just explain your point in your own words.
16-09-2026 19:39
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Why did John Headlee of the Corps of Engineers think it was important to invite a biogeochemist to give a presentation at a dredging conference?

If you don't take the time to see the presentation on the Internet, the single most important reason for the presentation was to disabuse the engineers of a serious misconception about "managing" the pH of dewatered dredge sediments.

I showed them all the water quality benefits of allowing the sediments to ripen to a pH of about 4-6. Pseudo chemists had convinced State regulators that dredged sediments who require "pH adjustment" up to within 0.5 pH units of that magic pH 7 which is somehow optimal.. I showed them how this released a lot of arsenic into groundwater, increased groundwater copper concentrations, dramatically increased export of TDS and salinity to surface water, and more than tripled export of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) to surface waters.

I had a very friendly and receptive audience among those engineers. I had successfully gotten the regulators to back off and rescind all mandates for "pH adjustment" (aka environmental chemotherapy) and rescind the designation of the sediments as "hazardous waste" requiring costly disposal.

I showed them how dredged sediment actually IMPROVE the quality of underlying ground water and drainage waters from the sites where they were placed upland. Just let them ripen to a safe pH of about 4-6, and DON'T provoke release of arsenic, copper, salts galore, dissolved organic carbon enough to provoke hypoxia, by artificially raising the pH with exogenous alkaline materials, such as the beet lime they applied to stir up so much trouble.

[quote]Im a BM wrote:
Dredge Spoils, Acid Sulfate Soils!

I was surprised to discover that an invited chemistry presentation that I gave to the US Army Corps of Engineers in 2008 can be found on the Internet.

https://dots.el.erdc.dren.mil/workshops/2008-04-15-doer-20_SPK_DMAttenuation_Northup.pdf

I don't know if this will show up as an actual link, or just a website address that I typed for others to copy.

It is HIGHLY relevant to the topic of this thread.

From the title page:
"Dredged Material and Acid Sulfate Soils

Biogeochemistry of Upland Placement of Dredged Sediments on Delta Peatland Soils

Sediment pH and Attenuation of Arsenic, Copper, Nitrate Nitrogen, and Dissolved Organic Carbon (DOC)

Robert R. Northup, Ph.D.
rnorthup@nature.berkeley.edu"


My presentation was on the second day of the US Army Corps of Engineers Dredging Conference, in Sacramento, California, April 16, 2008.

Note how the US government facilitates the publication of "buzzwords" such as "biogeochemistry" and "organic carbon".

The US Army Corps of Engineers seemed to be under the impression that this PhD character knew something about "pH" and "Acid Sulfate Soils", as if I were some kind of "chemist"

I've got EVERYONE fooled except YARP (Yellow And Red Parrot) and IBdaMann.

YARP, I double dog DARE you to open this US Army Corps of Engineers document on the Internet, the address listed above, ending in "...Attenuation_Northup.pdf"

You can prove you know more about the chemistry of pyrite oxidation, for example, by explaining the chemistry of what is WRONG with my 2008 presentation to the US Army Corps of Engineers. You don't have to say what "pH" or "buffering" actually IS, just show what's wrong with MY presentation about "pH" and "Acid Sulfate Soils".

The first one is a freebie: "There is NO SUCH THING as 'acid sulfate soil'. Buzzword!" And you can list all the other "no such thing" and "buzzword" and "something is not something else" to prove that I just do not understand chemistry. And readers will benefit from your CORRECT chemistry lesson.
16-09-2026 19:44
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
The Hostility of Alkaline Environments - IRON DEPRIVATION!

If the assertions made in IBdaMann's "Ocean Acidification Debunked" offer a teachable moment, it may be in regard to the "hostility" of alkaline environments.

"Alkaline environments are hostile to life, and require special adaptations in order to survive." - IBdaMann


With pH a little above 8, the ocean is mildly alkaline. Not particularly caustic.

But there is something hostile to life about this non-acidic pH condition.

The solubility of some inorganic forms of iron is very low at pH >8. The more oxidized form, ferric iron, iron(III), Fe3+ is virtually insoluble at sea water pH.

The reduced form of inorganic iron is soluble at sea water pH. Ferrous iron, iron(II), Fe2+, is soluble enough at pH >8, but it has a short life in an aerobic environment. Iron oxidizing bacteria use O2 as terminal electron acceptor to oxidize ferrous iron(II), Fe2+ to ferric iron(III), Fe3+, which is insoluble.

In both soil and sea water, the bioavailability of iron can be limiting.

Citrus plants can get enough iron from soil with pH >8, or even pH >7. Special adaptations are required to survive the hostile alkaline environment, and citrus isn't adapted. We have to acidify the soil if we want the citrus to thrive. Otherwise, it just can't get enough iron from the soil to grow.

Plants have many adaptations to get iron from alkaline soils. One trick is to chemically reduce ferric iron(III), Fe3+, into the soluble form of ferrous iron(II). Phenolic compounds, among others, act as reducing agents in soil, transforming ferric iron into soluble ferrous iron.

Fun fact: the classic assays for total phenolic content of vegetation use ferric iron as the test reagent. How much ferric iron they can reduce into a colored ferrous iron compound is directly proportional to the total number of phenolic groups present in solution.

Another way to get that stubborn iron to become bioavailable is to use chelating agents - organic acids capable of forming organometallic complexes with the insoluble ferric iron(III). They call them "siderophores", and roots exude them into the soil to chelate iron and make it available for root uptake.

In sea water, ferrous iron(ii) is soluble, but it is at high risk of being oxidized to insoluble form by iron oxidizing bacteria, before any plankton gets to use the iron as fertilizer for photosynthesis. Large scale fertilization experiments most often apply a ferrous iron salt, such as ferrous sulfate. Iron oxidizing bacteria will surely get any that the photosynthetic organisms don't catch first.

And ferric iron is simply insoluble in sea water. At least in inorganic form.

Organometallic complexation of ferric iron, such as ferric citrate, can make Fe3+ soluble at sea water pH.

Organometallic complexation of ferrous iron, such as ferrous citrate, can make Fe2+ remain soluble in sea water for much longer than inorganic ferrous iron. The reactive sites on ferrous iron(II) are occluded from oxidation by being bonded to organic ligands. Iron oxidizing bacteria can't oxidize ferrous iron in organometallic complexes.

About 99% of the natural iron dissolved in sea water is associated with organic matter, rather than present as an inorganic salt.

I'm out of time, but the whole hostility of alkaline environments to life provided a chance to bring iron in.

And ORGANIC ALKALINITY is a component of sea water total alkalinity.

That fraction of sea water acid neutralizing capacity supplied by deprotonated organic acid anions. It is what keeps iron bioavailable in sea water. Without the iron complexing activity of organic alkalinity in sea water, there wouldn't be enough iron to support almost any photosynthesis
16-09-2026 19:45
Into the NightProfile picture★★★★★
(24585)
Im a BM and sealover and Patricio and FakeGooglewrote:
THE MOST RELEVANT POSTS OF THIS THREAD ARE ALL COMPILED, beginning three posts down from the top of PAGE 26 (previous page)

Stop spamming.
Im a BM and sealover and Patricio and FakeGooglewrote:
I have already done quite well at learning chemistry and other basic science.

Many other chemists, literally thousands, cite my published chemistry research.

You deny chemistry and many theories of science.
Science is not a publication.
Science is not a research or study.
Science does not use consensus.
You don't get to quote everyone. Omniscience fallacy.

Im a BM and sealover and Patricio and FakeGooglewrote:
"A very small amount of CO2 in water (around 1%) will form carbolic acid."

THIS CLAIM IS ABSURD!

Carbolic acid, aka "phenol" "phenolic acid" or "benzenol", does NOT form from carbon dioxide combining with water.

Carbolic acid, chemical formula C6H5OH, has NOTHING to do with sea water or carbon dioxide.

YOU made this claim, Robert. You cannot blame you problem on me or anybody else.

Im a BM and sealover and Patricio and FakeGooglewrote:
The buffering capacity of sea water arises from the presence of oxyanions of weak acids, with bicarbonate ions and carbonate ions providing the overwhelming majority of the ocean's alkalinity (aka acid neutralizing capacity).

The absurd claim that water is a buffer for ANY acid, and the assertion that it is CARBOLIC acid forming from carbon dioxide, confirms the DISGUSTING DISHONESTY of the final words from "Into the Night's comments"

Bicarbonate is not a chemical.
Carbonate is not a chemical.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
It is YOUR claim that carbolic acid forms from carbon dioxide.
Water is a buffer for all acids.

Im a BM and sealover and Patricio and FakeGooglewrote:
...deleted whining...

Stop whining. Stop spamming. Stop blaming your problems on others.


The Parrot Killer

Debunked in my sig. - tmiddles

Google keeps track of paranoid talk and i'm not on their list. I've been evaluated and certified. - keepit

nuclear powered ships do not require nuclear fuel. - Swan

While it is true that fossils do not burn it is also true that fossil fuels burn very well - Swan
16-09-2026 19:46
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
IBdaMann wrote:
sealover wrote:Google, "Why use soil acidifier for citrus trees?"

Too funny! You believe everything on the internet; you think everything issued by the internet must be true.

... and you're a scientist.


In a rare example of honesty and accuracy, IBdaMann identifies me as a "scientist".

I only use Google AI as a substitute for my own brain when I want an example to show others.

I already knew that soil acidifiers of various kinds (elemental sulfur, aluminum sulfate, polysulfides of calcium, etc.) were sold to people who wanted to grow citrus in soil with pH > 6.5. A pH of 7.0 isn't low enough for citrus to get enough iron from the soil. Under aerobic conditions, iron solubility is highly pH dependent.

Another option is to leave the soil for the citrus with pH > 7, but just add the iron in organically complexed form, to remain soluble and bioavailable.

Google, "Can I give my citrus chelated iron instead of acidifying the soil?"

Google replies, "Yes, you can give your citrus chelated iron instead of acidifying the soil."

But Google later goes on to advise that.."* The drawback: Chelated iron is a short-term band-aid. It does not change the soil pH. The problem will keep coming back unless you fix the soil acidity in the long run."

Unless you are willing to give your citrus a little more chelated iron every growing season, you have to acidify the soil if you want the citrus to get enough iron.

The same principle applies in sea water. Chelated iron is bioavailable despite pH being greater than 8. Chelated iron is virtually the ONLY natural iron you can find dissolved in sea water. Brief fertilization with inorganic iron blown by the wind can fertilize brief blooms, but unless that iron becomes organically complexed, it soon precipitates out as it is oxidized.

Organic alkalinity is that part of the sea's acid neutralizing capacity that arises from organic anions, the conjugate bases of weak organic acids. It may be less than 1% of the sea's total alkalinity, but it can comprise up to 25% of the total alkalinity in submarine groundwater discharge entering the sea from coastal wetlands. The chelated iron contained in submarine groundwater discharge, carried by the organic alkalinity, is what fertilizes photosynthesis in the most productive waters of the ocean.
16-09-2026 19:48
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Into the Night wrote:
Im a BM wrote:
IBdaMann wrote:
[quote]sealover wrote:Google, "Why use soil acidifier for citrus trees?"

Too funny! You believe everything on the internet; you think everything issued by the internet must be true.

... and you're a scientist.


In a rare example of honesty and accuracy, IBdaMann identifies me as a "scientist".

Lie. Contextomy fallacy.
Im a BM wrote:
I only use Google AI as a substitute for my own brain when I want an example to show others.

This statement is correct.
Im a BM wrote:
I already knew that soil acidifiers of various kinds (elemental sulfur, aluminum sulfate, polysulfides of calcium, etc.) were sold to people who wanted to grow citrus in soil with pH > 6.5. A pH of 7.0 isn't low enough for citrus to get enough iron from the soil. Under aerobic conditions, iron solubility is highly pH dependent.

You cannot acidify an alkaline.
Sulfur is not an acid.
Aluminum sulfate is not an acid.
Polysulfide is not a chemical.
Iron is not soluble.
Im a BM wrote:
Another option is to leave the soil for the citrus with pH > 7, but just add the iron in organically complexed form, to remain soluble and bioavailable.
Iron is not organic.
Iron is not soluble.
'Bioavailable' is not a word.
Im a BM wrote:
Google, "Can I give my citrus chelated iron instead of acidifying the soil?"

Google replies, "Yes, you can give your citrus chelated iron instead of acidifying the soil."

It is not possible to acidify an alkaline.
Chelated is not a chemical.
Im a BM wrote:
But Google later goes on to advise that.."* The drawback: Chelated iron is a short-term band-aid. It does not change the soil pH. The problem will keep coming back unless you fix the soil acidity in the long run."

Chelated is not a chemical.
You cannot acidify an alkaline.
Im a BM wrote:
Unless you are willing to give your citrus a little more chelated iron every growing season, you have to acidify the soil if you want the citrus to get enough iron.

Chelated is not a chemical.
You cannot acidify an alkaline.
Im a BM wrote:
The same principle applies in sea water. Chelated iron is bioavailable despite pH being greater than 8. Chelated iron is virtually the ONLY natural iron you can find dissolved in sea water. Brief fertilization with inorganic iron blown by the wind can fertilize brief blooms, but unless that iron becomes organically complexed, it soon precipitates out as it is oxidized.

Chelated is not a chemical.
'Bioavailable' is not a word.
Iron is not pH.
Natural is not a chemical.
Iron is not soluble.
Iron is not a fertilizer.
Iron is not inorganic.
Iron is not organic.
It is not possible to percipitate what is not in solution.
Im a BM wrote:
Organic alkalinity is that part of the sea's acid neutralizing capacity that arises from organic anions, the conjugate bases of weak organic acids. It may be less than 1% of the sea's total alkalinity, but it can comprise up to 25% of the total alkalinity in submarine groundwater discharge entering the sea from coastal wetlands. The chelated iron contained in submarine groundwater discharge, carried by the organic alkalinity, is what fertilizes photosynthesis in the most productive waters of the ocean.

Alkalinity is not a chemical.
The ocean is alkaline.
Anion is not a chemical.
Submarines don't discharge groundwater.
It is not possible to fertilize photosynthesis.


Into the Night, I know that you will not understand this response to your comments. However, anyone viewing who passed high chemistry can.

"Chelated is not a chemical". Of course it's not! "Chelated" is what happens to a transition metal such as iron when it is complexed by an organic ligand at two different binding sites, in a ring structure. From the Greek word chele or chelos for "claw" of a crab. Grabbed between two claws, the transition metal is bound by formation of inner sphere complexes (covalent bonds) with the organic ligand.

"Sulfur is not an acid,"
Of course it's not! Elemental "yellow" sulfur added to soil is readily oxidized under aerobic conditions by sulfur oxidizing bacteria. They use oxygen, O2, as a terminal electron acceptor to oxidize the sulfur to sulfuric acid, using the reaction as a source of metabolic energy.
S + O2 + H2O = H2SO4

"Aluminum sulfate is not an acid."
Actually, it is. It is an acidic salt. The trivalent aluminum ion, Al3+ adsorbs to cation exchange sites as exchangeable acidity, and releases adsorbed H+ into solution. Al2(SO4)3 will lower soil pH.

"Polysulfide is not a chemical".
That's a matter of opinion, but calcium polysulfide is certainly a chemical. A polymer of CaS, its sulfide is readily oxidized under aerobic conditions by sulfur oxidizing bacteria in the soil. Yes, calcium polysulfide is a soil acidifying chemical.

"Iron is not a fertilizer."
That is certainly a matter of opinion. Iron deficiency is what limits citrus growth in alkaline soil. People seem to have agreed to call it "iron fertilizer" when they buy and sell it, and to call it "iron fertilization" when they attempt geoengineering schemes in the sea. Iron is only needed by organisms in the tiniest amount. A "trace" nutrient element. But you can't grow without it, on land or in the sea.

"Something is not something else" seems to be a theme that comes up again and again and again.

Nearly always irrelevant, but once in a while "science is not a chemical" provides a teachable moment.
16-09-2026 19:50
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Into the Night wrote:
Im a BM and sealover and Patricio wrote:
Anyone who can read can see how DISHONEST IBdaMann is.

You're the one with the socks, Robert.
You're the one trying to deny science.
You're the one trying to pretend to be a scientist.
Im a BM and sealover and Patricio wrote:
He clearly wrote, "the impact of a drop of the acid would be more pronounced on the sea water than on the pure water."

In response to how much pH would change upon addition of a drop of acid.

This statement is correct.
Im a BM and sealover and Patricio wrote:
In his flagrant, habitual DISHONESTY, IBdaMann now tries to claim that he said "..bigger impact on acid from sea water than I will from pure water, but I will in fact see bigger impact on acid.."

"..impact on acid.."
? WTF??? Not defined as change to pH. Not defined at all.

Acid is not pH, Robert.

[b]Im a BM and sealover and Patricio wrote:
But what IBdaMann actually said was "the impact of a drop of the acid.. on the sea water... on the pure water."
[/b]

No, he didn't. Don't put words in peoples mouths. Lie. Synthesis. Mantra 30a.
Im a BM and sealover and Patricio wrote:
DON'T TRY TO DENY YOUR OWN POSTS! You LYIN' motherpHucker!

He isn't. Lie. Synthesis.

You can't blame YOUR problems on anybody else, Robert.


As usual, you conveniently omitted the actual post and words of IBdaMann, so that you too could stand by your LIES along with him.

Neither of you has a clue how to measure alkalinity, but IBdaMann's actual comprehension of chemistry is superior to that of ITN. At least IBdaMann, eventually, figured out that pH = -log(H+), and therefore ANY solution with >1.0 M (H+) must have pH <0. He eventually realized that pH was an exponential function of base ten, and not the natural log. He eventually realized that his quip about "magical" acid with pH = 0.0 only revealed his ignorance.

But Into the Night conveniently omitted ALL of IBdaMann's original comments in order to do this reply. Had to go out of his way to remove the denied text.

IBdaMann absolutely asserted the impact on the water of a drop of acid, not the undefined "change to the acid". You pHuckin' LIARS are a waste of time to discuss actual chemistry with.

Anyway, MOST rivers and MOST cubic meters of river surface water entering the sea have pH >7. However, many natural rivers are naturally acidic.

The most naturally acidic rivers are a tiny minority where oxidation of ammonium or sulfides generates nitric acid or sulfuric acid. Some such streams can have pH well below 3.0 or even below pH 1.0 (see Dahlgren et al, Nature 1994, "California Acid Rock" is the title of the review article in the same issue of Nature). The first one Randy published about was NITRIC acid formed from oxidation of ammonium in the bedrock. Most such streams get their acid as sulfuric acid derived from the microbial oxidation of iron pyrite.

In second place for most acidic rivers are those acidified by ORGANIC acids from the vegetation. "Blackwater rivers" can have pH below 3, in the case of the Amazon tributaries of the Rio Negro, flowing out of exceptionally tannin rich rainforests growing on "acid white sand" soils. Blackwater rivers are dark with organic matter, getting their low pH from tannins (phenol, carboxylic acids) and humic acids.

It is irritating that scientifically illiterate trolls compulsively shit all over my threads at this website. But it is easy to scroll past their bullshit.

Into the Night insists that no river in the world is naturally acidic.

At least ITN conceded that rain can be naturally acidic. But he can't seem to comprehend that Henry's law makes the pH of about 5.6 the predictable equilibrium pH reached by pure water in contact with the atmosphere at sea level. Nor can he comprehend that anthropogenic sulfuric acid and nitric acid are what make some rainfall have pH significantly lower than 5.6, as low as 3.0 in "acid rain" and as low as pH 2.0 in "acid fog".

The local trolls aren't capable of comprehending the ocean's "carbonate system" of pH buffering, so they simply deny its existence.

Perhaps they have convinced each other that they are both credible as "scientists". I doubt that they have anyone else fooled.
16-09-2026 19:51
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
IBdaMann wrote:
Im a BM wrote:Science is not funny.

Question: Two cats begin to slide off a high roof; which one survives longer?
Answer: The one with the greater Mew! (μ).

Im a BM wrote: What is the system boundary, and what is the system's usable energy in the Dewey Decimal System?

Until you can express a system boundary, it would appear that there is no system.

Im a BM wrote: Google AI gives kind of a crappy, while accurate definition for the "carbonate system"

Let me know when Google AI provides a system boundary.

Im a BM wrote:Notice how they simply say "carbonate"

Did you just use the pronoun "they" to describe AI output?

Too funny!

Im a BM wrote:Because water itself is NOT a buffer for acid.

... unless you apply the definition for buffering, and then pure water, and thus dilution, becomes a buffer.


Let's give Google a chance to show that she knows WAY more science than any scientifically-illiterate Internet TROLL.

Google, "Does evaporation change the pH of water?"

Google say: "Yes, evaporation changes the pH of water by altering the concentration of dissolved substances. ...
Acid Concentration: If the water contains acids that do not easily evaporate, the loss of water volume concentrates these acids. This decreases the pH, making the water more acidic."


So then, please tell me Google, "Does carbonic acid evaporate more easily than water?"

Google says it's complicated... but...

"How does evaporation affect the pH of a solution that contains bicarbonate, HCO3-, and carbonate, CO3(2-)?"


Google says: "Evaporation removes water, which increases the concentration of both bicarbonate (HCO3-) and carbonate CO3(2-) ions. ... These ions act as a buffer. A buffer is a liquid that resists quick changes to its pH level."

One more question.

Tell me, Google, did the PhD biogeochemist known as "sealover" or "Im a BM" EVER even ONCE assert that "water does not evaporate"?

COME ON!

Do you really believe Google is THAT gullible?

Try another one in that case.

"At 20 degrees celcius, does liquid carbonic acid have more vapor pressure than liquid water?"

Google reassures us that, "No. Liquid water has higher vapor pressure than pure liquid carbonic acid at 20 degrees C."

That's what I thought!

Google, "Does evaporation act as a mechanism of pH buffering in water?

Google say: "No, evaporation does not act as a mechanism of pH buffering"


Okay, what about DILUTION?

Google, "Does dilution act as a mechanism of pH buffering?"

Google say: "No, dilution does not act as a mechanism of pH buffering"

That's what I thought!

Google, "what is the mechanism of pH buffering in sea water?"

Google say: "Seawater's pH is stabilized near pH 8.1 by the carbonate buffer system"

So, blame the system, I guess.
16-09-2026 19:53
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
Into the Night, you accomplish nothing of value by TROLLING everything I post.

The vast majority of your "is not" claims are incorrect.

You obviously never studied chemistry.

But I must correct the Rolaids formula, which changed in 1996, when they changed the spelling of "relief". It was dihydroxyl aluminum sodium carbonate. A different form of aluminum hydroxide, also known as carbaldrate. NaAl(OH)2CO3. Two thirds of its acid neutralizing capacity was aluminum hydroxide and one third was sodium carbonate.

Into the Night makes so many FALSE assertions about what "is not".

Let's just get one little science lesson out of it.

"Adsorb is not a word" - Into the Night


ITN isn't necessarily a LIAR who is aware the statement is incorrect. More likely, they didn't cover "adsorption" in his high school, and that's as far as he ever got in his "study" of chemistry.

"Adsorb" is indeed a word in chemistry, and an important one at that. I have used it so many times here, I'm surprised ITN didn't ever complain about it not existing before this. I guess it's like "organic carbon", a word that took ITN YEARS to decide was unacceptable.

Google, you are SO MUCH SMARTER than Into the Night!

Google, please tell us, "What does the term 'adsorb' mean in chemistry?"

I'm sure that Into the Night will be incapable of learning this and will come back and simply declare, as the King of All Terms, that there is "no such thing". But others who DID pass high school chemistry will get it.

Google is correct with the reply: "To adsorb means to gather atoms, ions, or molecules of a gas, liquid, or dissolved solid onto the surface of a solid or liquid material. It is a strict-surface level event, much like dust or magnetic filings sticking to the outside of a magnet."

My most frequent references to adsorption are in regard to cations adsorbing to cation exchange sites on soil surfaces. I have also mentioned ozone destroying agents adsorbing to the surface of nitric acid crystals high in the sky during stratospheric denitrification.

Into the Night wouldn't know, because he never studied chemistry.

One morning he woke up two years ago and suddenly discovered that "carbonate is not a chemical", and became OBSESSED with everything that is "not a chemical". For eight years of posting here before that, identifying what what "not a chemical" was NEVER Into the Night's "thing".

Today, Into the Night discovered that "adsorb is not a word". If he was paying attention, he had seen me use that "not a word" over and over for years.

Perhaps he'll come back with "there is no such thing as adsorption".

There is no such thing as a "chemist" who doesn't even know what adsorption is.



Into the Night wrote:
sealover wrote:
How does aluminum sulfate acidify soil when added as an amendment.

Aluminum sulfate is not an acid.
sealover wrote:
I mentioned that it can adsorb to CEC sites, exchanging out adsorbed protons, hydrogen ions or H+, for aluminum ions, Al3+

'adsorb' is not a word.
H+ is not a chemical.
Al3+ is not a chemical.
sealover wrote:
HOW DO YOU SPELL RELIEF? Rolaids was aluminum hydroxide, Al(OH)3.

Rolaids is not aluminum hydroxide.
sealover wrote:
Understanding how aluminum sulfate, Al2(SO4)3 behaves as an ACID might make more sense by knowing how Rolaids aluminum hydroxide, Al(OH)3 acts as an ANTACID.

Rolaids is not aluminum hydroxide.
Aluminum sulfate is not an acid.
sealover wrote:
Aluminum hydroxide acts as a BASE to neutralize stomach acid.

Aluminum hydroxide is not an alkaline.
sealover wrote:
Aluminum sulfate acts as an ACID to acidify soil.

Aluminum sulfate is not an acid.
16-09-2026 19:54
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
IBdaMann wrote:
Im a BM wrote: The local trolls aren't capable of comprehending the ocean's "carbonate system" of pH buffering, so they simply deny its existence.

Too funny. What is the system boundary? What is the system's usable energy?


Science is not funny.

What is the system boundary, and what is the system's usable energy in the Dewey Decimal System?

Google AI gives kind of a crappy, while accurate definition for the "carbonate system" in water chemistry. Water chemistry textbooks provide better definitions for it, but we'll take Google for a spin anyway.

Google, "How does the carbonate system provide pH buffering in sea water?"

"The carbonate system acts as a natural shield for seawater. It keeps the pH stable - usually hovering around 8.1 - by swapping chemical forms to absorb or release hydrogen ions, H+...
Three main chemical players make up this system:
1. Carbonic acid (H2CO3)
2. Bicarbonate (HCO3-)
3. Carbonate CO3(2-)"

Notice how they simply say "carbonate" and everyone understands that it means CO3(2-), regardless of whether we call it category or chemical.
And everyone understands that it plays a major role in seawater pH buffering.

Because water itself is NOT a buffer for acid.

Google AI's little story goes on to offer links to legitimate information about ocean acidification and how it impacts CaCO3 shell forming organisms.
16-09-2026 19:56
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
IBdaMann wrote:
Im a BM wrote:Science is not funny.

Question: Two cats begin to slide off a high roof; which one survives longer?
Answer: The one with the greater Mew! (μ).

Im a BM wrote: What is the system boundary, and what is the system's usable energy in the Dewey Decimal System?

Until you can express a system boundary, it would appear that there is no system.

Im a BM wrote: Google AI gives kind of a crappy, while accurate definition for the "carbonate system"

Let me know when Google AI provides a system boundary.

Im a BM wrote:Notice how they simply say "carbonate"

Did you just use the pronoun "they" to describe AI output?

Too funny!

Im a BM wrote:Because water itself is NOT a buffer for acid.

... unless you apply the definition for buffering, and then pure water, and thus dilution, becomes a buffer.


I'll let Google prove that she is SMARTER than YOU!

Google, "Is the concentration of carbonic acid greater at the sea floor than at the sea surface?"


Google knows more about this shit than IBdaMann or Into the Night can begin to even imagine.

Google say: "The concentration of carbonic acid is generally greater at the sea floor than at the sea surface due to deeper waters accumulating more carbon dioxide from respiration and organic decomposition over time. You can read more about these vertical profiles on the NOAA Ocean Acidification Program."


Of course, Google is CORRECT. IBdaMann's ABSURD claim that carbonic acid can only be found in the top three meters of sea water is just more proof that he is a SCIENTIFICALLY-ILLITERATE TROLL.

Into the Night's ABSURD claim that CO2 and carbonic acid are too light to sink in sea water is just as STUPID. ITN's claim that CO2 and H2CO3 (carbonic acid) are too "light" to be found in deep water is effing STUPID. Liquid carbonic acid is more dense than water. Dissolved CO2 is more dense than water.

Even if they weren't sinking down from the surface, CO2 and carbonic acid both get GENERATED at the sea floor by aerobic decomposition and respiration.

Of course, where there isn't enough O2 available to support CO2 generation, microbial sulfate reduction can still exploit the organic carbon that sinks to the sea floor. Instead of generating CO2 and carbonic acid, sulfate reduction generates carbonate ion, CO3(2-). It does so on a large enough scale to keep the sea above pH 8.1, despite the constant input of "carbonic acid gas" (CO2) from the atmosphere.
16-09-2026 19:58
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
[quote]Im a BM wrote:
"There is no 'decomposition and respiration' on the sea floor." - ITN

When Into the Night asserts that "There is no...", it is nearly always in reference to something that anyone can easily confirm that there IS.

I could Google the question, "Is there 'decomposition and respiration' on the sea floor?". However, I already know the answer.

Of COURSE there is "decomposition and respiration' on the sea floor!

Every living multicellular animal down there that uses oxygen is performing respiration on the sea floor. Respiration is when an organism uses oxygen, O2, as terminal electron acceptor to oxidize organic carbon. Such as ourselves, and every sea floor critter that uses some kind of gill to get oxygen from the water. Like ourselves, these aerobic sea floor creatures put out carbon dioxide, CO2, as the inorganic (oxidized) carbon product generated by respiration of organic carbon. Is is a source of fresh CO2 delivered right to the sea floor, using locally available resources (oxygen, O2, and organic carbon, "R").

And YES, decomposition of organic matter that falls to the sea floor DOES occur. It can be a very slow process at such low temperature, but it happens. Decomposition of sea floor organic carbon by microorganisms can occur aerobically using oxygen, O2, as terminal electron acceptor. Like respiration, the oxidized (inorganic) carbon product is carbon dioxide, CO2, generated deep down on the sea floor. One example would be aerobic methane-oxidizing bacteria in a sea floor microsite where methane is emitted from anaerobic sediment fermentation or geologic processes.
CH4 + 2O2 = CO2 + 2H2O

On the other hand, microbial decomposition of organic carbon deposited on the sea floor can occur in the low oxygen zone slightly beneath the sea floor surface. Whereas sea water rarely has more than 8 ppm O2, it typically contains 2700 ppm sulfate. When the small amount of O2 is depleted by aerobic decomposition or respiration, microbial sulfate reduction can occur using the abundant sulfate in sea water. Unlike aerobic decomposition, anaerobic decomposition via sulfate reduction generates CARBONATE ION, CO3(2-) as the oxidized (i.e. "inorganic") carbon product. Let's consider a methane-oxidizing, sulfate-reducing bacteria on the sea floor.
CH4 + SO4(2-) = H2S + H2O + CO3(2-)
However, this process usually occurs in the presence of ferrous iron, Fe2+, so rather than emitting H2S, it forms iron pyrite, FeS2
Fe(OH)2 + 2H2S = FeS2 + 2H2O


Although the sea is absolutely loaded with available sulfate ion, SO4(2-), it is only able to penetrate a very short distance into the sea floor via passive diffusion. The vast majority of carbonate ions, CO3(2-) entering the sea are derived from microbial sulfate reduction occurring where a current of flowing water carries sulfate ion into low-oxygen, organic-carbon-rich sediment. Submarine groundwater discharge from coastal wetlands is the biggest source of carbonate ions entering sea water. The alkalinity is derived primarily from microbial sulfate reduction. "Submarine" means it occurs beneath the surface of the sea. "Groundwater" means it is of terrestrial origin, flowing off the land above sea level, carried beneath the surface water in underground flow paths, and entering the sea through seeps that are below the sea level surface.

Into the Night asserts that "There is no.." about a LOT of things.

Where ITN goes FULL RETARD is when he insists that "There is no such thing as...", and it is nearly always something that anyone can look up to verify the actual existence of.

Just from this little essay, ITN has repeated OVER AND OVER AND OVER that "There is no such thing as 'terminal electron acceptor'."

I invite ANYONE to look this one up. It is a useful chemistry term to learn.

And ANYONE can very easily verify that there IS respiration and decomposition on the sea floor.

Even if ITN is willing to repeat his sentence ten thousand times that "there is no such thing".
16-09-2026 19:59
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
"Respiration" is the exclusive domain of the MITOCHONDRIA.

Aerobic eukaryotic organisms have mitochondria in their cells. These mitochondria use oxygen, O2, as terminal electron acceptor to oxidize organic carbon, usually in the form of glucose. Most of the energy released is used to generate ATP. That ATP is used by the rest of the cell (non-mitochondrial component) as the energy currency for metabolism.

Liver flukes provide an example of how different the metabolic pathways are.

Juvenile liver flukes can use oxygen, in their mitochondria, to generate ATP from aerobic glucose oxidation (i.e. respiration). Adult liver flukes cannot. Adult liver flukes are strictly anaerobic, and their mitochondria are present but inactive. Adult liver flukes get their ATP by performing anaerobic fermentation of glucose, in a very inefficient process. But just because a cell has a mitochondria capable of aerobic respiration, it doesn't mean they HAVE to. They can still get ATP the old fashioned way, as organisms used to do before any oxygen was available for use on land or in the sea.

The mitochondria was an independent bacteria that formed a symbiosis with a much larger eukaryotic cell. The partnership enabled the exploitation of a newly available resource in the environment. The mitochondria was one of the first bacteria to evolve the capacity to generate ATP, using oxygen as a terminal electron acceptor to oxidize organic carbon. As a symbiotic partner, it enabled its host cell to get far greater energy yields from organic carbon oxidation.

There was no "oxygen catastrophe" or mass extinction that ever occurred because a powerful new oxidant in the environment was suddenly present at high enough concentration to kill everybody. To the contrary, it opened up new niches for organisms to get more metabolic energy from the organic carbon they oxidized for a living. There was fierce competition for this precious new resource. Bacteria that oxidized sulfur, iron, manganese, ammonium, and other reductants competed to get close to the cyanobacteria putting out the O2.

As oxygen became more and more available, a niche opened up for a partnership between mitochondrial bacteria and an anaerobic eukaryotic cell. They would be able to outcompete everyone else because they could get so much more bang for the buck from organic carbon oxidation.


"There is no 'decomposition and respiration' on the sea floor." - ITN

When Into the Night asserts that "There is no...", it is nearly always in reference to something that anyone can easily confirm that there IS.

I could Google the question, "Is there 'decomposition and respiration' on the sea floor?". However, I already know the answer.

Of COURSE there is "decomposition and respiration' on the sea floor!

Every living multicellular animal down there that uses oxygen is performing respiration on the sea floor. Respiration is when an organism uses oxygen, O2, as terminal electron acceptor to oxidize organic carbon. Such as ourselves, and every sea floor critter that uses some kind of gill to get oxygen from the water. Like ourselves, these aerobic sea floor creatures put out carbon dioxide, CO2, as the inorganic (oxidized) carbon product generated by respiration of organic carbon. Is is a source of fresh CO2 delivered right to the sea floor, using locally available resources (oxygen, O2, and organic carbon, "R").

And YES, decomposition of organic matter that falls to the sea floor DOES occur. It can be a very slow process at such low temperature, but it happens. Decomposition of sea floor organic carbon by microorganisms can occur aerobically using oxygen, O2, as terminal electron acceptor. Like respiration, the oxidized (inorganic) carbon product is carbon dioxide, CO2, generated deep down on the sea floor. One example would be aerobic methane-oxidizing bacteria in a sea floor microsite where methane is emitted from anaerobic sediment fermentation or geologic processes.
CH4 + 2O2 = CO2 + 2H2O

On the other hand, microbial decomposition of organic carbon deposited on the sea floor can occur in the low oxygen zone slightly beneath the sea floor surface. Whereas sea water rarely has more than 8 ppm O2, it typically contains 2700 ppm sulfate. When the small amount of O2 is depleted by aerobic decomposition or respiration, microbial sulfate reduction can occur using the abundant sulfate in sea water. Unlike aerobic decomposition, anaerobic decomposition via sulfate reduction generates CARBONATE ION, CO3(2-) as the oxidized (i.e. "inorganic") carbon product. Let's consider a methane-oxidizing, sulfate-reducing bacteria on the sea floor.
CH4 + SO4(2-) = H2S + H2O + CO3(2-)
However, this process usually occurs in the presence of ferrous iron, Fe2+, so rather than emitting H2S, it forms iron pyrite, FeS2
Fe(OH)2 + 2H2S = FeS2 + 2H2O


Although the sea is absolutely loaded with available sulfate ion, SO4(2-), it is only able to penetrate a very short distance into the sea floor via passive diffusion. The vast majority of carbonate ions, CO3(2-) entering the sea are derived from microbial sulfate reduction occurring where a current of flowing water carries sulfate ion into low-oxygen, organic-carbon-rich sediment. Submarine groundwater discharge from coastal wetlands is the biggest source of carbonate ions entering sea water. The alkalinity is derived primarily from microbial sulfate reduction. "Submarine" means it occurs beneath the surface of the sea. "Groundwater" means it is of terrestrial origin, flowing off the land above sea level, carried beneath the surface water in underground flow paths, and entering the sea through seeps that are below the sea level surface.

Into the Night asserts that "There is no.." about a LOT of things.

Where ITN goes FULL RETARD is when he insists that "There is no such thing as...", and it is nearly always something that anyone can look up to verify the actual existence of.

Just from this little essay, ITN has repeated OVER AND OVER AND OVER that "There is no such thing as 'terminal electron acceptor'."

I invite ANYONE to look this one up. It is a useful chemistry term to learn.

And ANYONE can very easily verify that there IS respiration and decomposition on the sea floor.

Even if ITN is willing to repeat his sentence ten thousand times that "there is no such thing".

Is the sea floor "barren"?

HELL NO!

The reason we have underground deposits of petroleum today is because the ancient sea floor of the shallow sea of the continental shelf was anything but "barren". Productive photosynthesis at the surface rained down organic matter and dead microorganisms which piled up on the sea floor. These materials were rich in lipids. Having relatively high carbon to oxygen ratio, and relatively low carbon to hydrogen ratio, geologic metamorphism under high temperature and pressure squeezed and baked out all the oxygen bonded to the carbon, forming H2O, and leaving behind pure hydrocarbons.

In contrast, organic matter piling up in ancient swamps had relatively high carbon to hydrogen ratio and relatively low carbon to oxygen ratio, being comprise predominantly of carbohydrate, lignin, and tannin. During geologic metamorphism, the high oxygen content consumed all the hydrogen, as these atoms were cleaved off the carbon to form H2O. This baked and squeezed out all the hydrogen as well as the oxygen, leaving behind nearly pure carbon coal.
16-09-2026 20:01
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
"Evaporation makes the pH of about 8.2 the predictable equilibrium pH reached by sea water." - IBdaMann

IBdaMann wants to be sure that the whole world knows he is a scientifically-illiterate moron!

The pH buffering in sea water results from the presence of conjugate bases of weak acids. Bicarbonate ion, HCO3-, and carbonate ion, CO3(2-) account for about 99% of the ocean's acid neutralizing capacity (i.e. alkalinity).

Rather than get into the details of the carbonate system, or the ABSURDITY of invoking evaporation as a mechanism of pH regulation or buffering with a predictable "equilibrium" value..

It is NOT a chemical "equilibrium" that regulates sea water pH, although the chemical equilibria of carbonic acid dissociation and bicarbonate dissociation play a major role. Ocean pH is NOT in "equilibrium" at pH 8.2. It is actually what scientists call a "steady state", because new matter and energy constantly enter the system.

There are two opposing processes that control the steady state pH of sea water.

1. The acidifying impact of "carbonic acid gas" (i.e. carbon dioxide or CO2) entering the sea from the atmosphere.

2. The acid neutralizing impact of carbonate ions, CO3(2-) entering the sea, primarily from the process of microbial sulfate reduction.

Organisms control both processes. Organisms cause CO2 to enter the atmosphere from the land and dissolve into sea water. Organisms cause carbonate ions to enter sea water. Neither process can be predicted or calculated acccording to any equilibrium. The combined effect of the two processes keeps the sea at a steady state pH of about 8.2

This thread was intended to be a place where microbial sulfate reduction and its management for enhanced alkalinity production could be discussed.

Keeps getting shit on by trolls who think dilution and evaporation buffer pH, and ocean acidification is a Communist hoax.
Edited on 16-09-2026 20:02
16-09-2026 20:04
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
IBdaMann wrote:
Im a BM wrote: Actually, the sulfate ion, SO4(2-), an anion with two negative charges, IS a chemical and it CAN be reduced.

Nope. Learn basic science.

The sulfate ion [ SO4(2-) ] is an attribute of a particular category.

You still haven't learned what a "category" is.
You still haven't learned that water evaporates.
You still don't understand the nature and reason of definitions.
You still delude yourseld into believing that you are omniscient and that you somehow "see" the ocean being depleted of its alkalinity, despite this obviously not being the case.

You still think you're a chemist.
You still think your WACKY religion is science.

If you were to become an instructor, you could only teach science denial.


"Sulfate cannot be reduced"... "Sulfate is not a chemical"....

Google has access to CITABLE REFERENCES to back up her shit!

Google Inguiry (not posed as question): "Peer-reviewed scientific papers with the term 'sulfate reduction' in the title"


Gosh, there are a LOT of them!

Apparently, thousands of so-called "scientists" are under the impression that sulfate IS a chemical that CAN be reduced!

There are so many papers out there about "sulfate reduction" that Google offers four major categories of such papers to narrow the search.

"Sulfate Reduction in Soil: Effect on Redox Potential and pH... blah blah blah"

This would be the large group of papers of greatest relevance to the discussion. It is in the waterlogged (low oxygen) wetland soil that sulfate reduction effects on pH are of greatest significance to restoring alkalinity to the ocean.

"Redox potential" is about the oxidation-reduction conditions. Sulfate reduction cannot occur under oxidizing conditions where oxygen, O2, is present. The virtually opposite biochemical process of sulfide oxidation can occur if O2 is present, transforming the products of sulfate reduction into sulfuric acid.

The effects of sulfate reduction, because the sulfate ion, (SO4(2-), a CHEMICAL, actually CAN be chemically reduced, on pH are to raise it.

Sulfate reduction transforms organic carbon into carbonate ion, CO3(2-), which is alkaline CHEMICAL that raises pH. Sulfate reduction uses the sulfate ion, SO4(2-) as the CHEMICAL needed to act as terminal electron acceptor (oxidant, oxidizer, or oxidizing agent) to oxidize organic carbon for metabolic energy.

Aerobic oxidation of organic carbon, using O2 as terminal electron acceptor generates the ACIDIC inorganic carbon product CO2.

Anaerobic oxidation of organic carbon, using sulfate ion, SO4(2-) as oxidant, generates the ALKALINE inorganic carbon product carbonate ion, CO3(2-)
16-09-2026 20:06
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
"Google knows that soil has no pH." - IBdaMann

"You do not have a degree in chemistry. That much is painfully obvious."
- IBdaMann


Anyone following the discussion at climate-debate.com knows that IBdaMann is a compulsive LIAR. Even in the rare instance where IBdaMann cites something other than his own infallible omniscience as a source, without verification it is safest to assume the IBdaMann is simply LYING.

In this instance, it would appear that IBdaMann is claiming that Google is a citable source that supports the RETARDED assertion that "soil has no pH".

Google does confirm that IBdaMann has a reputation as an internet troll who aggressively and repetitively disputes the validity of mainstream science.

But there is no pHucking way that Google would agree that "soil has no pH", no matter how the inquiry is worded!

Let's try two extremes - one straightforward question and one attempt to spin a question that might make Google say something really stupid.

Google inquiry#1: "Does soil have pH?"

Google inquiry #2: "Why do scientists claim that soil has no pH?"

Haven't done it yet, but I predict that neither inquiry will produce a result that agrees with the made up shit IBdaMann posted regarding Google and soil pH.

Now, having read both answers, I don't have the patience to copy them.

Okay, I'll copy the first sentence and a half from GOOGLE:

"Yes, soil does have pH. It measures how acidic or alkaline the soil is.."
(Google, 2026)
If alligators can be amphibians, soil can be something that doesn't have pH.

A convoluted word game can make anything mean what IBdaMann wants it to.

In my own measurement of soil pH, which I tabulated for widely-cited peer-reviewed scientific publications, we had to say how we did it and give a proper name to the parameter. I only ever once published data where what we measured was actually the pH of the free soil solution in an intact soil column in the field. You can only do that when its raining in the forests we studied. Otherwise, you have to take a sample from the field to the lab and add water to it before you can get a pH reading. My two data columns were for soil slurries made with either pure water, or dilute calcium chloride.

The pure water soil slurry gives a pH reading that reflects the magnitude of hydrogen ion activity found in free soil solution. The (pH neutral) calcium chloride combines with the soil in a slurry that reveals a pH often more than a full pH unit lower than the pH measured with pure water. This is because calcium ions exchange for hydrogen ions adsorbed to soil surface cation exchange sites, putting those hydrogen ions out into solution for measurement.

It's hard to know why IBdaMann obsesses so much on what he claims to be MY disbelief in the process of water evaporation. I am well aware that water evaporates. It must have been at least sixty five years ago when it was first explained to me. It made sense then, and it still makes sense now.

I have never been a member of the Communist Party, and I have never asserted in any way that "water does not evaporate". I think it was nearly ten kilocalories per mole to get liquid water to break those hydrogen bonds to become free as unattached gas molecules. I just looked it up, it's 40.65 kilojoules per mole to get water to evaporate. And water CAN evaporate! I have never been in a water evaporation denial cult as part of a WACKY religion.
IBdaMann wrote:
Im a BM wrote:
IBdaMann wrote:
Im a BM wrote: Actually, the sulfate ion, SO4(2-), an anion with two negative charges, IS a chemical and it CAN be reduced.

Nope. Learn basic science.

The sulfate ion [ SO4(2-) ] is an attribute of a particular category.

You still haven't learned what a "category" is.
You still haven't learned that water evaporates.
You still don't understand the nature and reason of definitions.
You still delude yourseld into believing that you are omniscient and that you somehow "see" the ocean being depleted of its alkalinity, despite this obviously not being the case.

You still think you're a chemist.
You still think your WACKY religion is science.

If you were to become an instructor, you could only teach science denial.
Google has access to CITABLE REFERENCES to back up her shit!

Irrelevant. Google has access to CITABLE SCIENCE but strangely you can never seem to find any no matter how much you Google.

Google has access to CITABLE DEFINITIONS but strangely you can never produce any no matter how much you Google.

Google knows that soil has no pH, despite what many misinformed cosplaying laymen, such as yourself, have been led to believe by their religious clergy. Google knows what chemists know, i.e. that only solutions made with soil as an ingredient can have a pH.

You shouldn't have slept through middle school.

Im a BM wrote:Google Inguiry (not posed as question): "Peer-reviewed gibberish papers with the term 'sulfate reduction' in the title"

Gosh, there are a LOT of them!

Too funny!
Copilot Inquiry (not posed as a question): "Science of Sulfate Reduction"

Copilot's Response: Sulfate reduction is the process in which members of the sulfate class — that is, chemical compounds containing the sulfate anion SO₄²⁻ — are reduced to members of the sulfide class, which contain sulfur in the −2 oxidation state (such as S²⁻ or H₂S). The sulfate class includes compounds like sodium sulfate, magnesium sulfate, ammonium sulfate, and calcium sulfate. None of these are "a sulfate chemical" in the sense of a standalone molecule; they are sulfate salts, each with its own cation paired with the SO₄²⁻ anion.

During sulfate reduction, the sulfate anion undergoes a multi‑electron reduction sequence. The sulfur atom in SO₄²⁻ starts in the +6 oxidation state and is reduced stepwise through intermediates such as sulfite (SO₃²⁻) until it reaches the −2 oxidation state found in sulfide species. The overall redox transformation is:

SO₄²⁻ → SO₃²⁻ → S²⁻ → H₂S

This is a reaction pathway, not a category identity.
The sulfate class remains sulfate until the reduction occurs; the sulfide class is only formed after the reduction.

Biological sulfate reduction uses electron donors (such as organic acids or hydrogen) and enzyme‑mediated steps involving APS (adenosine‑5′‑phosphosulfate) and sulfite reductase. Abiotic sulfate reduction can occur under high temperature, high pressure, or in the presence of strong reductants. In both cases, the process converts a sulfate‑containing compound into a sulfide‑containing compound, but the categories themselves remain distinct.


Im a BM wrote:Apparently, thousands of cosplaying "scientists" are under the mistaken impression that sulfate IS a chemical that CAN be reduced!

Yep. It is likely that every single one of them is an undereducated Democrat who believes that thermodynamics can be violated by "human activity."

Im a BM wrote:There are so many papers out there about "sulfate reduction" that Google offers four major categories of such papers to narrow the search.

Here's the next question to add to your list of unanswered questions: How many mistaken morons are sufficient to transform their misconception into absolute truth?

You should abandon your science denial and ditch your WACKY religion. Embrace science and accept that water evaporates.
16-09-2026 20:07
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
IBdaMann wrote:
sealover wrote: one more attempt to attach a file
Let's see if it let me attach the pdf file


I'll attach the abstract. The parts in red are just boolsch't. The underlined phrases are the calls for greater funding and greater government control while downplaying any need to provide specifics.

Submarine groundwater discharge (SGD) links terrestrial and marine systems, but has often been overlooked in coastal nutrient budgets because it is difficult to quantify. In this Review, we examine SGD nutrient fluxes in over 200 locations globally, explain their impact on biogeochemistry and discuss broader management implications. SGD nutrient fluxes exceed river inputs in ~60% of study sites, with median total SGD fluxes of 6.0 mmol m−2 per day for dissolved inorganic nitrogen, 0.1 mmol m−2 per day for dissolved inorganic phosphorus and 6.5 mmol m−2 per day for dissolved silicate. SGD nitrogen input (mostly in the form of ammonium and dissolved organic nitrogen) often mitigates nitrogen limitation in coastal waters, since SGD tends to have high nitrogen concentrations relative to phosphorus (76% of studies showed N
values above the Redfield ratio
). It is notable that most investigations do not distinguish saline and fresh SGD, although they have different properties. Saline SGD is a ubiquitous, diffuse pathway releasing mostly recycled nutrients to global coastal waters, whereas fresh SGD is occasionally a local, point source of new nutrients. SGD-derived nutrient fluxes must be considered in water quality management plans, as these inputs can promote eutrophication if not properly managed.


A casual glance will reveal that this document is intended to say absolutely nothing while filling the mandatory quota of white space with text. The thesis statement, i.e. that greater funding and control are required in this area, is pushed by fear, of course. This document seeks to engender a panic surrounding the flourishing of plants and algaes that might happen if this funding and control are not increased per this alarm warning. Did you catch that? The threat is possible "eutrophication", i.e. that plants and algaes might flourish.

sealover, the first line of the abstract says that SGD links terrestrial and marine systems. Does that mean that SGD links Army tactical vehicles to Navy aircraft carriers? ... or does it link terrestrial data centers with ocean drilling platforms?


I wish that this had been a more typical response from IBdaMann to my posts.

He located an EXCELLENT review article by Moore et al (IBdaMann didn't bother citing the author, title, or source) from which he posted the abstract.

Very first sentence, "Submarine groundwater discharge"..

No complaints from IBdaMann that this term required more definition. Because it did not. Marine biologists reading the paper knew exactly what the term referred to without the authors having to provide a definition. Scientists know how to look up terms they don't already know when they read such a paper.

To my absolute delight, this paper speciated ORGANIC nitrogen and ORGANIC phosphorus, in addition to classic measure of nitrate, ammonium, and orthophosphate.

No complaints from IBdaMann that these terms ("organic nitrogen" and "organic phosphorus") required more definition. Because they did not. Any reader who passed an introductory college-level chemistry class (without cheating!) learned what these terms mean. Or would at least know how to look them up in a matter of less than a minute, to find the definition that scientists all use.

IBdaMann did a lot of weird highlighting in red, but otherwise did not address any of the scientific points in the abstract. His commentary is strictly politics.

There is no way to know from IBdaMann's comments if he had the slightest clue what the review article was actually about.

But he had a lot to say about the evil agenda of the scientists who somehow seemed to be claiming that "greater funding and control are required in this area" (I couldn't find that one in the abstract!).

"This document seeks to engender a panic..."

Really? I read it several times, and I missed that part.

"..this alarm warning.." WTF?

What is the "alarm"?

The authors are encouraging other researchers not to omit the nutrient inputs to marine ecosystems entering the sea as submarine groundwater discharge.

They do point out their potential to contribute to eutrophication.

For example, if excess nitrogen fertilizer has already elevated the bioavailable nitrogen levels to potentially create a "dead zone", it might be a good idea to know if submarine groundwater discharge of bioavailable nitrogen in the same area might have an amplifying effect on the process.

Basically, the authors are pointing out that submarine groundwater discharge is a long overlooked but very important source of nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorus entering marine ecosystems.

I can't blame the authors for not trying to take on EVERYTHING, but I wish they had included data for bioavailable iron, pH, and alkalinity (preferably speciated into carbonate alkalinity, bicarbonate alkalinity, and ideally ORGANIC alkalinity).

The timing of the review paper suggests they were not yet aware that ORGANIC alkalinity, the acid neutralizing and pH buffering capacity that arises from organic anions of deprotonated organic acids, is a significant contributor to total alkalinity in submarine groundwater discharge. Organic alkalinity is also what makes enough iron become bioavailable to support photosynthesis.

Anyway, this was IBdaMann introducing himself to me.

Damn shame that he didn't make a habit of finding excellent papers to post the abstract. This was basically the only time he did.

His dubious political analysis is not particularly informative.

Perhaps more revealing, he didn't try to even comment on the chemistry.

He hadn't yet discovered that "There is no such thing as 'organic nitrogen'."
16-09-2026 20:08
Into the NightProfile picture★★★★★
(24585)
Im a BM wrote:
He DID use alcohol. Phenols are a subset of alcohols. All phenols are alcohols, but not all alcohols are phenols. Something you or your second rate sidekick would have learned if you ever studied chemistry.

Phenol is not a chemical.
Alcohol is not a chemical.
Im a BM wrote:
Or you had multiple opportunities more recently to learn this, as it came up repeatedly in the ridiculous "lignin is a carbohydrate" thing.

Phenols are aromatic alcohols. All other alcohols are aliphatic alcohols.

And no word game can transform the chemistry of lignin to make it possible to classify it as a carbohydrate.

Lignin is not a chemical.
Carbohydrate is not a chemical.
Alcohol is not a chemical.
Aliphatic is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
Physical properties of carbonic acid versus dissolved carbon dioxide:

Less than 1% of the CO2 that dissolves in water forms a covalent bond to water molecules to become something quite different - carbonic acid.

The more than 99% of dissolved CO2 that remains as CO2 is free to evaporate as a natural gas at ambient temperature.

Which also destroys the carbonic acid.
Im a BM wrote:
However, the rate at which CO2 goes from the sea into the atmosphere is slower than the rate at which CO2 goes from the atmosphere into the sea.

The sea is a net "sink" for atmospheric carbon dioxide.

Not possible. The concentration of CO2 in water is the same as the air above it.
You are denying Henry's Law again.

Im a BM wrote:
Dissolved carbon dioxide is not what makes the pH of natural rainfall about 5.6, slightly acidic. It is the less than 1% of dissolved carbon dioxide transformed into carbonic acid that supplies the protons in solution.
Carbonic acid is not a proton.
It is not possible to measure the pH of Earth's rainfall.
It is not possible to measure Earth's rainfall quantity either.

Im a BM wrote:
Unlike carbon dioxide, carbonic acid is not a gas. It is very difficult to get it into the vapor phase at ambient temperature. The sea would have to boil.

Evaporation does NOT neutralize any acid.

Evaporation does indeed neutralize carbonic acid.
So does CO2 venting.
Im a BM wrote:
"The limitless ocean water keeps the average ocean pH exactly where it is."

Less than 1% of the ocean's alkalinity (i.e. pH buffering capacity) comes from its water content. The tiny fraction of water molecules that dissociate to release hydroxide into solution is negligible compared to the other buffers present. The other 99+% comes from oxyanions of weak acids, mainly bicarbonate ions and some from carbonate ions. (can't wait to see Into the Night say "bicarbonate is not a chemical" again, as if that meant something relevant to ANY discussion)

Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Hydroxide is not a chemical.
Bicarbonate is not a chemical.
Carbonate is not a chemical.
Water is a buffer for all acids.

Im a BM wrote:
Back to the one drop of acid in one liter of pure water, which IBdaMann and Into the Night both agree is well buffered against significant pH change.

Regardless of the concentration of acid used to make the one drop, the pH of the pure water WILL decrease.

If you add that drop of acid to 100 liters of pure water, the pH will still drop, but not as much. That one drop of acid in a MILLION liters of pure water will lower the pH, but maybe not enough to measure the difference.

Irrelevance fallacy.

Im a BM wrote:
But the "limitless" ocean water is up against a "limitless" atmosphere. It isn't just one drop of acid being added.

The atmosphere is not an acid.

Im a BM wrote:
And the 0.0000001 moles per liter of hydroxide ion in pure water is so tiny it makes pure water the LEAST buffered wet stuff you can find.

And I'm only bothering to respond to IBdaMann because I want to see Parrot Boy triple down and insist that carbon dioxide DOES form carbolic acid in water.

Hydroxide is not a chemical.
I will not agree with YOUR claim that carbon dioxide forms carbolic acid in water.
Water is a buffer for all acids.

Im a BM wrote:
And then claim to have knowledge of chemistry far superior to my own.

You deny chemistry. You deny many theories of science.

Im a BM wrote:
I also learned what happens when that acidic solution evaporates, i.e. it's a CO2 cycle. CO2 in the atmosphere gets into precipitation making carbonic acid, evaporates and returns to the atmosphere.

Carbon dioxide is not an acid.
Carbon dioxide is not a cycle.
Carbonic acid is not a precipitate of carbon dioxide.
Carbon dioxide vents to the atmosphere.
Carbonic acid is neutralized by this process.
You are ignoring Henry's Law again.

Im a BM wrote: Did you read Into the Night's post?

I'm far more familiar with my own posts;

You try to deny your own posts!
You try to blame YOUR posts on others!

Im a BM wrote:
I know what I mean when I write something.

Buzzwords have no meaning.
Gibber-babble has no meaning.

Im a BM wrote:
1. The ocean is losing its alkalinity.
2. Earth's average equilibrium temperature is rising.
3. Climate Change is making the world worse.

Alkalinity is not a chemical.
It is not possible to measure the temperature of the Earth.
Climate cannot change.

Im a BM wrote:
What possible mechanism would allow water molecules to prevent the pH from changing when acid is added?

Water is a buffer for all acids.


The Parrot Killer

Debunked in my sig. - tmiddles

Google keeps track of paranoid talk and i'm not on their list. I've been evaluated and certified. - keepit

nuclear powered ships do not require nuclear fuel. - Swan

While it is true that fossils do not burn it is also true that fossil fuels burn very well - Swan
16-09-2026 20:11
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
"Sulfate cannot be reduced." - Into the Night

"Copilots response: Sulfate reduction is the process.. During sulfate reduction the sulfate anion undergoes a multi electron reduction sequence.." - IBdaMann

Yes, the sulfate anion CAN be reduced, and it couldn't care less whether or not anyone wants to call sulfate a "chemical".

Too bad IBdaMann didn't transcribe it, because Copilot surely included more information about the fact that BACTERIA are doing most of the sulfate reduction in the world.

Hey, IBdaMann, why don't you ask Copilot about how microbial sulfate reduction creates carbonate ions, CO3(2-) as the oxidized (inorganic) carbon product?

THEN you'll be closer to understanding what keeps the sea at pH > 8.2, despite the continuous net flux of CO2 from the atmosphere into the sea.

According to Google, 0.032 GIGATONS of CO2 per day goes into the sea from the atmosphere, and does NOT come back out to the sky. That makes more and more carbonic acid every day!

Sulfate CAN be reduced, and DOES get reduced, and regardless of whether or not one wants to label sulfate as a "chemical", the chemical behavior of sulfate reduction is an acid neutralizing process.

So what if you don't like the label "chemical"?

The "chemical" label and the dubious choice to deny it is totally irrelevant to the chemistry of sulfate reduction as an acid neutralizing process.

[quote]Im a BM wrote:
"Evaporation makes the pH of about 8.2 the predictable equilibrium pH reached by sea water." - IBdaMann

IBdaMann wants to be sure that the whole world knows he is a scientifically-illiterate moron!

The pH buffering in sea water results from the presence of conjugate bases of weak acids. Bicarbonate ion, HCO3-, and carbonate ion, CO3(2-) account for about 99% of the ocean's acid neutralizing capacity (i.e. alkalinity).

Rather than get into the details of the carbonate system, or the ABSURDITY of invoking evaporation as a mechanism of pH regulation or buffering with a predictable "equilibrium" value..

It is NOT a chemical "equilibrium" that regulates sea water pH, although the chemical equilibria of carbonic acid dissociation and bicarbonate dissociation play a major role. Ocean pH is NOT in "equilibrium" at pH 8.2. It is actually what scientists call a "steady state", because new matter and energy constantly enter the system.

There are two opposing processes that control the steady state pH of sea water.

1. The acidifying impact of "carbonic acid gas" (i.e. carbon dioxide or CO2) entering the sea from the atmosphere.

2. The acid neutralizing impact of carbonate ions, CO3(2-) entering the sea, primarily from the process of microbial sulfate reduction.

Organisms control both processes. Organisms cause CO2 to enter the atmosphere from the land and dissolve into sea water. Organisms cause carbonate ions to enter sea water. Neither process can be predicted or calculated acccording to any equilibrium. The combined effect of the two processes keeps the sea at a steady state pH of about 8.2

This thread was intended to be a place where microbial sulfate reduction and its management for enhanced alkalinity production could be discussed.

Keeps getting shit on by trolls who think dilution and evaporation buffer pH, and ocean acidification is a Communist hoax.


Because real chemists in the real world know what "organic carbon" and "organic nitrogen" are.

---------------------------------------

But you don't have to be a real chemist in the real world to understand what "organic nitrogen" is.

You could just look it up in a dictionary or chemistry textbook. Or ask GOOGLE!

Google inquiry: "What does the term 'organic nitrogen' mean in chemistry?"


Because it is a real term used in chemistry, and a common one at that, Google has no trouble finding the definition.

Google say: "Organic nitrogen means nitrogen that is chemically bound inside a carbon-containing molecule. These are molecules tied to living things, such as amino acids, proteins, DNA, and urea. It is different than inorganic nitrogen, like ammonia or nitrate, which does not contain carbon."


Google's answer is mostly correct... But it contains a glaring error. Urea is NOT organic nitrogen. Urea does contain both carbon and nitrogen. But the carbon in urea is INORGANIC carbon. Maybe it's a technicality that not all chemists adhere to, but I was taught that "organic nitrogen" had to be attached to ORGANIC carbon to qualify as "organic". Urea is CO(NH2)2, a carbonyl group attached to two amine groups.

I'll go ahead and double check.. Well, Google insists that the carbonyl group is actually organic carbon, as long as it is part of a larger organic molecule. I wouln't call two amine groups an "organic molecule", but...

Well, anyone who wants a more complete tutorial can do what I just did and Google the question:

"Is the carbonyl group considered 'organic carbon' if it is attached to two amine groups?"


Google insists that urea IS organic nitrogen, because the carbonyl group IS considered to be "fully organic, as it is part of a standard carbon-based molecular framework containing carbon-nitrogen and carbon-oxygen covalent bonds."

I won't copy it here now, but Google goes on with long with a multi-point section under the heading, "Why it Is Organic Carbon"

And I stand corrected. There is some chemistry that even I didn't fully know!
16-09-2026 20:15
Into the NightProfile picture★★★★★
(24585)
Im a BM wrote:
You, as the reader, are expected to be scientifically literate enough to understand the word "organic" in this article.

The term "organic acids" is so common, with 150 years of usage among scientists, that no research article needs to repeat the definition again.

Void argument fallacy.
Im a BM wrote:
The "'organic carbon' crap" is what you will find in chemistry research articles.

Readers of peer-reviewed scientific articles are not expected to be mind readers.

Readers ARE presumed to be scientifically literate enough to understand BASIC terms like "organic", "organic carbon", "organic acid", and even "organic alkalinity".

Carbon is not organic.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Science is not an article.
Science is not a research or study.
Science does not use consensus.
Void argument fallacy.

Im a BM wrote:
Referring to the "stupid author" as being the legitimate object of grievance because he failed to spoon feed remedial education for the potential reader who never studied enough chemistry to get anything out of the article anyway...

No, the failure here is the arrogance of the READER.

It is the responsibility for any author to define their terms.
Gibber-babble is meaningless.
Buzzwords are meaningless.

Im a BM wrote:
But, isn't IBdaMann omniscient about all things scientific?

He knows what science is, and he knows quite a few theories of science.
You deny and ignore many theories of science.

Im a BM wrote:
Shouldn't he be explaining to the author what the words REALLY mean?

Void argument fallacy. Every theory of science defines it's terms.

Im a BM wrote:
Maybe he will get a Nobel Prize for proving that there is no such thing as organic carbon.

Carbon is not organic.
Science is not a prize.


The Parrot Killer

Debunked in my sig. - tmiddles

Google keeps track of paranoid talk and i'm not on their list. I've been evaluated and certified. - keepit

nuclear powered ships do not require nuclear fuel. - Swan

While it is true that fossils do not burn it is also true that fossil fuels burn very well - Swan
16-09-2026 20:34
Into the NightProfile picture★★★★★
(24585)
Im a BM wrote:
So, why wasn't the term "dissolved organic nitrogen" highlighted in RED?

Nitrogen is not organic.

Im a BM wrote:
More than a year after IBdaMann posted this, he realized that there is NO SUCH THING as "organic carbon" or "organic nitrogen".

Carbon is not organic.
Nitrogen is not organic.

Im a BM wrote:
Yet, the abstract he posted was from an article that was among the first to show how much dissolved organic nitrogen is contained in submarine groundwater discharge.

Nitrogen is not organic.
Submarines don't discharge groundwater.

Im a BM wrote:
Dissolved organic nitrogen is very real and very important.

Nitrogen is not organic.

Im a BM wrote:
Yes, this was one of the first responses to my very first post.

It begins with an unsourced cut and paste abstract of perfectly valid science.

Science is not cut and paste.

Im a BM wrote:
This is followed by bizarre anti scientific analysis.

"This document seeks to engender panic.."

Science is not a document.
Science does not seek to engender panic.

Im a BM wrote:
The "scientific" analysis is purely political, if not simply delusional.

Science has no politics.

Im a BM wrote:
However, the abstract contains something the fills me with pride.

It mentions that "..ammonium and dissolved organic nitrogen.." were the main forms of nitrogen in submarine groundwater discharge.

Your own narcissism is your own problem.
Ammonium is not a chemical.
Nitrogen is not organic.
Submarines don't discharge groundwater.

Im a BM wrote:
A search of scientific papers reveals that prior to 1995, the term "dissolved organic nitrogen" appears in the title of just three papers.

Nitrogen is not organic.
Science is not a paper.

[b]Im a BM wrote:
One of them was my own, "Determination of dissolved organic nitrogen using persulfate oxidation..." (1994, Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis).

Nitrogen is not organic.
Persulfate is not a chemical.
Science is not a paper.

Im a BM wrote:
We developed a new method to measure dissolved organic nitrogen because the classic Kjeldahl digest was too cumbersome, slow, dangerous, and inaccurate.
[

Nitrogen is not organic.

Im a BM wrote:
But dissolved organic nitrogen didn't really get much attention until after 1995.

Nitrogen is not organic.

Im a BM wrote:
That was the year I published the paper in the journal Nature.

Nature is a shit rag.
Science is not a magazine or journal.
Science is not a paper.

Im a BM wrote:
The first sentence was:

"The importance of dissolved organic nitrogen (DON) in ecosystem nutrient fluxes and plant nutrition is only beginning to be appreciated."

Nitrogen is not organic.
'Ecosystem' is not a word.
Nutrient is not a flux.

Im a BM wrote:
The same issue of Nature (1995) includes a review article about the significance of my paper:

Science is not a paper.
Science does not use consensus.
Science is not a magazine or journal.

Im a BM wrote:
"New cog in the nitrogen cycle". (easy to look up with just those words)

Before that, virtually nobody was even trying to measure dissolved organic nitrogen in waters (soil water, ground water, surface water)

Nitrogen is not a cycle.
Nitrogen is not organic.
Nitrogen is not water.
Nitrogen is not dirt.

Im a BM wrote:
They knew that it existed as a theoretical component, but assumed it was negligible.

It is now standard fare to include measure of dissolved organic nitrogen, in addition to nitrate, ammonium, and sometimes nitrite, in water samples.

Nitrogen is not organic.
Nitrate is not a chemical.
Ammonium is not a chemical.
Nitrite is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
Otherwise they miss what is often a major component of the total nitrogen.

So, I am very proud of this contribution I made to real world science.

Nitrogen is not a compound.
You deny and discard many theories of science.
Go learn what 'real' means.
Science is not a magazine.
Science is not a journal.
Science is not a paper.

Im a BM wrote:
Persulfate oxidation has also now largely replaced the Kjeldahl digest to measure organic nitrogen. Something else I am proud of.

But I am MOST proud that OTHER discoveries I published are frequently cited in newer work related to climate change.

Persulfate is not a chemical.
Nitrogen is not organic.
Science is not a 'discovery'.
Science is not a cite.
Science is not a paper.
Science is not a magazine.
Science is not a journal.
Climate cannot change.

Im a BM wrote:
For example, the importance of plant polyphenols (tannins) for sequestration of carbon into stable organic matter with very long mean residence time in soil.

Polyphenol is not a chemical.
Tannin is not a chemical.
Carbon is not a sequester.
Carbon is not organic.
Carbon is not a residence.
Carbon is not dirt.

Im a BM wrote:
For example, the importance of plant polyphenols for minimizing the emission of nitrous oxide, a very powerful greenhouse gas.

Polyphenol is not a chemical.
No gas or vapor has the capability to warm the Earth.
You are ignoring the 1st law of thermodynamics again.

Im a BM wrote:
For example, the importance of plant mycorrhizal associations for facilitating the sequestration of carbon and minimizing nitrous oxide emissions.

Carbon is not a sequester.
Carbon is not nitrous oxide.
No gas or vapor is capable of warming the Earth.
You are ignoring the 1st law of thermodynamics again.

Im a BM wrote:
On the other hand, having published those widely cited papers, I can allow them to speak for themselves. Those who have cited me in their own papers can elaborate on the significance without my help.

Science is not a cite.
Science is not a paper.
Gibber-babble has no significance.
Buzzwords have no significance.

Im a BM wrote:
Meanwhile, my research into the biogeochemistry of coastal wetland groundwater in the Sacramento-San Joaquin delta is all about the SOURCE of submarine groundwater discharge. That data is NOT available in any scientific journals.

There is no such thing as biogeochemistry.
Submarines do not discharge groundwater.
Science is not a journal.
Science is not data.
Gibber-babble is not data.
Buzzwords are not data.

Im a BM wrote:
Unfortunately, the abstract that IBdaMann cut and pasted did NOT reference data for ALKALINITY in submarine groundwater discharge - the thread topic.

Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Submarines do not discharge groundwater.
There is no data for a buzzword.


The Parrot Killer

Debunked in my sig. - tmiddles

Google keeps track of paranoid talk and i'm not on their list. I've been evaluated and certified. - keepit

nuclear powered ships do not require nuclear fuel. - Swan

While it is true that fossils do not burn it is also true that fossil fuels burn very well - Swan
16-09-2026 20:46
Into the NightProfile picture★★★★★
(24585)
Im a BM wrote:
Organic Alkalinity and Potential Significance for Ocean "Acidification"

Alikalinity is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
IBdaMann found an excellent research paper and posted it.

The most important contribution of this paper was to point out that organic alkalinity is an overlooked contributor to total alkalinity.

Science is not a paper.
Science is not a research or study.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
Kind of reminds me how what most scientists called the most important contribution of my 1995 paper in NATURE was to point out that organic nitrogen is an overlooked contributor to total nitrogen.

Science is not a paper.
Science is not a magazine.
Science is not a journal.
Nature is a shit rag.
Nitrogen is not organic.

Im a BM wrote:
Organic acids tend to be weak acids. That makes them good buffers.

Citric acid, for example, only partially deprotonates at near neutral pH.

Some of it remains present as citric acid, with proton still attached.

Some of it deprotonates, dissociating into hydrogen cation (H+) and citrate anion.

Citrate is not a chemical.
(H+) is not a chemical.
Citric acid is not a proton.

Im a BM wrote:
Citrate buffers work best in the slightly acidic range, as they can neutralize a proton by protonating a citrate anion to form citric acid which remains protonated. Or some of the citric acid can deprotonate into citrate anion, and that proton can neutralize any added base (OH-).

Citrate is not a chemical.
You cannot neutralize a proton.
(OH-) is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
But the buffering capacity of organic alkalinity doesn't offer much help with regard to ocean "acidification". Organic alkalinity is only the tiniest fraction of the sea's total alkalinity, way below 1%.

Alkalinity is not a chemical.
You cannot acidify an alkaline.

Im a BM wrote:
On the other hand, organic alkalinity can comprise 25% of total alkalinity in groundwater of some wetlands, according to colleagues of mine.

Alkalinity is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
Most places it is a lot less than that, but it is still a contributor in the alkalinity of submarine groundwater discharge from coastal wetlands.

Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Submarines do not discharge groundwater.
Submarines do not travel in coastal wetlands.

Im a BM wrote:
But the most relevant feature of organic alkalinity with regard to ocean acidification is the metal-complexing capacity of organic anions.

You cannot acidify an alkaline.
Metal is not complex.
Anion is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
There would not be enough iron in seawater to support photosynthesis without metal complexing organic anions chelating iron to keep it soluble.

Metal is not complex.
Anion is not a chemical.
Chelating is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
Without enough iron to support photosynthesis, inorganic carbon dissolved in sea water would not get transformed into organic carbon, neutralizing ocean acidification.

Carbon is not inorganic.
Carbon is not organic.
You cannot acidify an alkaline.

Im a BM wrote:
So, organic alkalinity is actually very important.

Alkalinity is not a chemical.


The Parrot Killer

Debunked in my sig. - tmiddles

Google keeps track of paranoid talk and i'm not on their list. I've been evaluated and certified. - keepit

nuclear powered ships do not require nuclear fuel. - Swan

While it is true that fossils do not burn it is also true that fossil fuels burn very well - Swan
16-09-2026 20:48
Into the NightProfile picture★★★★★
(24585)
Im a BM wrote:
Into the Night explains how the "carbolic acid" formed from some of the carbon dioxide dissolved in sea water has any pH acidifying effect neutralized by dilution because "water itself is a buffer for acid"

This post by IBdaMann was within hours of my very first post at this website.

You cannot blame your problems on anybody else, Robert.
YOU claimed carbon dioxide forms carbolic acid on contact with water.
Carbon dioxide is not an acid.
Water is a buffer for all acids.


The Parrot Killer

Debunked in my sig. - tmiddles

Google keeps track of paranoid talk and i'm not on their list. I've been evaluated and certified. - keepit

nuclear powered ships do not require nuclear fuel. - Swan

While it is true that fossils do not burn it is also true that fossil fuels burn very well - Swan
16-09-2026 20:55
Into the NightProfile picture★★★★★
(24585)
Im a BM wrote:
Imagine a coastline where the rising sea level is creeping up into the saltwater wetlands. Little by little, the estuary is being submerged. In a few decades it will be completely underwater.

When the sea level was lower, the low tide was at an elevation well below the estuary soil surface. There was a steep hydraulic gradient to drain water out for a little while. This enabled sulfate rich sea water to move through the organic carbon rich, low oxygen wetland sediment. In so doing, sulfate reducing bacteria were supplied with the substrate they needed to use as a terminal electron acceptor to oxidize organic carbon to acquire metabolic energy. As the estuary water drained out at low tide, it carried with it the alkalinity (carbonate and bicarbonate ions) generated during sulfate reduction.

Hydraulic is not a gradient.
Sulfate is not a chemical.
Carbon is not organic.
Carbon is not a sediment.
Sulfate is not a bacterium.
There is no such thing as 'terminal electron acceptor'.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Carbonate is not a chemical.
Bicarbonate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.

Im a BM wrote:
Now that the sea level is higher, the low tide isn't as low anymore. There is less elevation difference between low tide and land surface. Less of a hydraulic gradient to drive sea water through the sediments. Less sulfate reduction and less alkalinity provided to the ocean.

The ocean level is not changing.
The elevation of any tide and the surface is zero feet, zero inches.
Hydraulic is not a gradient.
Seawater is not a sediment.
Sulfate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
Now picture a simple wind turbine or sea wave powered pump off the edge of the estuary. It is pumping sea water a meter or two uphill into the estuary at low tide. There is now more hydraulic pressure to push sea water through the sediments and bring about sulfate reduction and alkalinity generation. The reservoir of organic carbon is already there, lacking only a sufficient hydraulic gradient to get sea water to pass through it.

A wind turbine is not hydraulic pressure.
Seawater is not a sediment.
Sulfate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Carbon is not organic.
Carbon is not hydraulics.

Im a BM wrote:
It might be enough to have a pipe transport the sea water from the pump up on to the estuary a hundred meters back from the edge. More sulfate reduction and alkalinity generation could be facilitated if a berm is constructed of sediment along the edge of the estuary to delay the lateral flow of water off the surface back to sea at low tide.

Sulfate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Water is not a sediment.

Im a BM wrote:
Even without actively pumping any sea water, a berm alone could accomplish much of the same objective. If the top of the berm is lower than the high tide, it can fill up with sea water. When the tide goes back down, the berm will hold back the water to keep it on the estuary a while longer. Infiltrating sea water into the sediments rather than flowing off the surface back out to sea.

Seawater is not sediment.

Im a BM wrote:
We could assist the estuary to do again what it used to do so well before the sea level got so high. Supplying alkalinity to marine ecosystems.

The ocean level isn't rising.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Ecosystem is not a word.


The Parrot Killer

Debunked in my sig. - tmiddles

Google keeps track of paranoid talk and i'm not on their list. I've been evaluated and certified. - keepit

nuclear powered ships do not require nuclear fuel. - Swan

While it is true that fossils do not burn it is also true that fossil fuels burn very well - Swan
Edited on 16-09-2026 20:57
16-09-2026 21:09
Into the NightProfile picture★★★★★
(24585)
Im a BM wrote:
"Sulfate cannot be reduced." - Into the Night

"Copilots response: Sulfate reduction is the process.. During sulfate reduction the sulfate anion undergoes a multi electron reduction sequence.." - IBdaMann

Sulfate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.

Im a BM wrote:
Yes, the sulfate anion CAN be reduced, and it couldn't care less whether or not anyone wants to call sulfate a "chemical".

Sulfate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.

Im a BM wrote:
Too bad IBdaMann didn't transcribe it, because Copilot surely included more information about the fact that BACTERIA are doing most of the sulfate reduction in the world.

Sulfate cannot be reduced.
Sulfate is not a bacterium.
Sulfate is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
Hey, IBdaMann, why don't you ask Copilot about how microbial sulfate reduction creates carbonate ions, CO3(2-) as the oxidized (inorganic) carbon product?

Sulfate is not a microbe.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.
Sulfate is not a chemical.
Carbonate is not a chemical.
CO3(2-) is not a chemical.
Carbon is not inorganic.
Carbon is not oxygen.
Carbon is not a compound.

Im a BM wrote:
THEN you'll be closer to understanding what keeps the sea at pH > 8.2, despite the continuous net flux of CO2 from the atmosphere into the sea.

It is not possible to measure the pH of the oceans.
Carbon dioxide is not an acid.
The net flux of carbon dioxide into or from the ocean is zero.
You are ignoring Henry's Law again.

Im a BM wrote:
According to Google, 0.032 GIGATONS of CO2 per day goes into the sea from the atmosphere, and does NOT come back out to the sky. That makes more and more carbonic acid every day!

You are ignoring Henry's Law again.
Carbon dioxide is not carbonic acid.
Carbon dioxide is not an acid at all.

Im a BM wrote:
Sulfate CAN be reduced, and DOES get reduced, and regardless of whether or not one wants to label sulfate as a "chemical", the chemical behavior of sulfate reduction is an acid neutralizing process.

Sulfate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.

Im a BM wrote:
So what if you don't like the label "chemical"?

The "chemical" label and the dubious choice to deny it is totally irrelevant to the chemistry of sulfate reduction as an acid neutralizing process.

Sulfate cannot be reduced.
Sulfate is not a chemical.
You cannot neutralize any acid with a buzzword.

Im a BM wrote:
The pH buffering in sea water results from the presence of conjugate bases of weak acids. Bicarbonate ion, HCO3-, and carbonate ion, CO3(2-) account for about 99% of the ocean's acid neutralizing capacity (i.e. alkalinity).

Bicarbonate is not a chemical.
Carbonate is not a chemical.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
HCO3- is not a chemica.
CO3(2-) is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
Rather than get into the details of the carbonate system, or the ABSURDITY of invoking evaporation as a mechanism of pH regulation or buffering with a predictable "equilibrium" value..

Carbonate is not a system.
Carbonate is not a chemical.
pH is not a regulator.

Im a BM wrote:
It is NOT a chemical "equilibrium" that regulates sea water pH, although the chemical equilibria of carbonic acid dissociation and bicarbonate dissociation play a major role. Ocean pH is NOT in "equilibrium" at pH 8.2. It is actually what scientists call a "steady state", because new matter and energy constantly enter the system.

pH is not a regulator.
Bicarbonate isnot a chemical.
It is not possible to measure the pH of the ocean.
You are ignoring Henry's Law again.
Water evaporates.


The Parrot Killer

Debunked in my sig. - tmiddles

Google keeps track of paranoid talk and i'm not on their list. I've been evaluated and certified. - keepit

nuclear powered ships do not require nuclear fuel. - Swan

While it is true that fossils do not burn it is also true that fossil fuels burn very well - Swan
17-09-2026 01:45
Im a BM
★★★★★
(4131)
THE MOST RELEVANT POSTS OF THIS THREAD ARE COMPILED, beginning three posts down from the TOP OF PAGE 26, continuing through page 27

According to IBdaMann, the senior troll at climate-debate.com, every time Into the Night writes one of these "(something) is not (something else)" sentences to me, he is "correcting" my "errors". Furthermore, IBdaMann assures me that this should be of educational value to me and to anyone else viewing it.

Apparently, my many errors include the erroneous assertions that:

* hydraulic is a gradient
* sulfate is a bacterium
* carbon is a sediment
* alkalinity is a chemical
* seawater is a sediment
* a wind turbine is hydraulic pressure
* carbon is hydraulics
* water is a sediment

The list goes on with plenty of FORMULAIC REPETITION.


We are all smarter now after reading these informative corrections!


Into the Night wrote:
Im a BM wrote:
Imagine a coastline where the rising sea level is creeping up into the saltwater wetlands. Little by little, the estuary is being submerged. In a few decades it will be completely underwater.

When the sea level was lower, the low tide was at an elevation well below the estuary soil surface. There was a steep hydraulic gradient to drain water out for a little while. This enabled sulfate rich sea water to move through the organic carbon rich, low oxygen wetland sediment. In so doing, sulfate reducing bacteria were supplied with the substrate they needed to use as a terminal electron acceptor to oxidize organic carbon to acquire metabolic energy. As the estuary water drained out at low tide, it carried with it the alkalinity (carbonate and bicarbonate ions) generated during sulfate reduction.

Hydraulic is not a gradient.
Sulfate is not a chemical.
Carbon is not organic.
Carbon is not a sediment.
Sulfate is not a bacterium.
There is no such thing as 'terminal electron acceptor'.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Carbonate is not a chemical.
Bicarbonate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.

Im a BM wrote:
Now that the sea level is higher, the low tide isn't as low anymore. There is less elevation difference between low tide and land surface. Less of a hydraulic gradient to drive sea water through the sediments. Less sulfate reduction and less alkalinity provided to the ocean.

The ocean level is not changing.
The elevation of any tide and the surface is zero feet, zero inches.
Hydraulic is not a gradient.
Seawater is not a sediment.
Sulfate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.

Im a BM wrote:
Now picture a simple wind turbine or sea wave powered pump off the edge of the estuary. It is pumping sea water a meter or two uphill into the estuary at low tide. There is now more hydraulic pressure to push sea water through the sediments and bring about sulfate reduction and alkalinity generation. The reservoir of organic carbon is already there, lacking only a sufficient hydraulic gradient to get sea water to pass through it.

A wind turbine is not hydraulic pressure.
Seawater is not a sediment.
Sulfate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Carbon is not organic.
Carbon is not hydraulics.

Im a BM wrote:
It might be enough to have a pipe transport the sea water from the pump up on to the estuary a hundred meters back from the edge. More sulfate reduction and alkalinity generation could be facilitated if a berm is constructed of sediment along the edge of the estuary to delay the lateral flow of water off the surface back to sea at low tide.

Sulfate is not a chemical.
Sulfate cannot be reduced.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Water is not a sediment.

Im a BM wrote:
Even without actively pumping any sea water, a berm alone could accomplish much of the same objective. If the top of the berm is lower than the high tide, it can fill up with sea water. When the tide goes back down, the berm will hold back the water to keep it on the estuary a while longer. Infiltrating sea water into the sediments rather than flowing off the surface back out to sea.

Seawater is not sediment.

Im a BM wrote:
We could assist the estuary to do again what it used to do so well before the sea level got so high. Supplying alkalinity to marine ecosystems.

The ocean level isn't rising.
Alkalinity is not a chemical.
Ecosystem is not a word.


Actually, ecosystem is a word.

THE MOST RELEVANT POSTS OF THIS THREAD ARE COMPILED, beginning three posts down from the TOP OF PAGE 26, continuing through page 27

Edited on 17-09-2026 01:53
17-09-2026 06:43
Into the NightProfile picture★★★★★
(24585)
Im a BM wrote:
THE MOST RELEVANT POSTS OF THIS THREAD ARE COMPILED, beginning three posts down from the TOP OF PAGE 26, continuing through page 27

According to IBdaMann, the senior troll at climate-debate.com, every time Into the Night writes one of these "(something) is not (something else)" sentences to me, he is "correcting" my "errors". Furthermore, IBdaMann assures me that this should be of educational value to me and to anyone else viewing it.

Apparently, my many errors include the erroneous assertions that:

* hydraulic is a gradient
* sulfate is a bacterium
* carbon is a sediment
* alkalinity is a chemical
* seawater is a sediment
* a wind turbine is hydraulic pressure
* carbon is hydraulics
* water is a sediment

The list goes on with plenty of FORMULAIC REPETITION.


We are all smarter now after reading these informative corrections!
Actually, ecosystem is a word.

I doubt you will be any smarter. You are too hooked on your meaningless buzzwords, gibber-babble, and your pretending. Your narcissism is part of you.

Ecosystem is not a word.


The Parrot Killer

Debunked in my sig. - tmiddles

Google keeps track of paranoid talk and i'm not on their list. I've been evaluated and certified. - keepit

nuclear powered ships do not require nuclear fuel. - Swan

While it is true that fossils do not burn it is also true that fossil fuels burn very well - Swan
17-09-2026 16:01
sealover
★★★★★
(2184)
"Sulfate cannot be reduced." - Into the Night

Yet another unsupported contrarian assertion that contradicts reality.

"Copilots response: Sulfate reduction is the process.. During sulfate reduction the sulfate anion undergoes a multi electron reduction sequence.." - IBdaMann

Yes, the sulfate anion CAN be reduced, and it couldn't care less whether or not anyone wants to call sulfate a "chemical".

Too bad IBdaMann didn't transcribe it, because Copilot surely included more information about the fact that BACTERIA are doing most of the sulfate reduction in the world.

Hey, IBdaMann, why don't you ask Copilot about how microbial sulfate reduction creates carbonate ions, CO3(2-) as the oxidized (inorganic) carbon product?

THEN you'll be closer to understanding what keeps the sea at pH > 8.2, despite the continuous net flux of CO2 from the atmosphere into the sea.

According to Google, 0.032 GIGATONS of CO2 per day goes into the sea from the atmosphere, and does NOT come back out to the sky. That makes more and more carbonic acid every day!

Sulfate CAN be reduced, and DOES get reduced, and regardless of whether or not one wants to label sulfate as a "chemical", the chemical behavior of sulfate reduction is an acid neutralizing process.

So what if you don't like the label "chemical"?

The "chemical" label and the dubious choice to deny it is totally irrelevant to the chemistry of sulfate reduction as an acid neutralizing process.

[quote]Im a BM wrote:
"Evaporation makes the pH of about 8.2 the predictable equilibrium pH reached by sea water." - IBdaMann

IBdaMann wants to be sure that the whole world knows he is a scientifically-illiterate moron!

The pH buffering in sea water results from the presence of conjugate bases of weak acids. Bicarbonate ion, HCO3-, and carbonate ion, CO3(2-) account for about 99% of the ocean's acid neutralizing capacity (i.e. alkalinity).

Rather than get into the details of the carbonate system, or the ABSURDITY of invoking evaporation as a mechanism of pH regulation or buffering with a predictable "equilibrium" value..

It is NOT a chemical "equilibrium" that regulates sea water pH, although the chemical equilibria of carbonic acid dissociation and bicarbonate dissociation play a major role. Ocean pH is NOT in "equilibrium" at pH 8.2. It is actually what scientists call a "steady state", because new matter and energy constantly enter the system.

There are two opposing processes that control the steady state pH of sea water.

1. The acidifying impact of "carbonic acid gas" (i.e. carbon dioxide or CO2) entering the sea from the atmosphere.

2. The acid neutralizing impact of carbonate ions, CO3(2-) entering the sea, primarily from the process of microbial sulfate reduction.

Organisms control both processes. Organisms cause CO2 to enter the atmosphere from the land and dissolve into sea water. Organisms cause carbonate ions to enter sea water. Neither process can be predicted or calculated acccording to any equilibrium. The combined effect of the two processes keeps the sea at a steady state pH of about 8.2

This thread was intended to be a place where microbial sulfate reduction and its management for enhanced alkalinity production could be discussed.

Keeps getting shit on by trolls who think dilution and evaporation buffer pH, and ocean acidification is a Communist hoax.


Because real chemists in the real world know what "organic carbon" and "organic nitrogen" are.

---------------------------------------

But you don't have to be a real chemist in the real world to understand what "organic nitrogen" is.

You could just look it up in a dictionary or chemistry textbook. Or ask GOOGLE!

Google inquiry: "What does the term 'organic nitrogen' mean in chemistry?"


Because it is a real term used in chemistry, and a common one at that, Google has no trouble finding the definition.

Google say: "Organic nitrogen means nitrogen that is chemically bound inside a carbon-containing molecule. These are molecules tied to living things, such as amino acids, proteins, DNA, and urea. It is different than inorganic nitrogen, like ammonia or nitrate, which does not contain carbon."


Google's answer is mostly correct... But it contains a glaring error. Urea is NOT organic nitrogen. Urea does contain both carbon and nitrogen. But the carbon in urea is INORGANIC carbon. Maybe it's a technicality that not all chemists adhere to, but I was taught that "organic nitrogen" had to be attached to ORGANIC carbon to qualify as "organic". Urea is CO(NH2)2, a carbonyl group attached to two amine groups.

I'll go ahead and double check.. Well, Google insists that the carbonyl group is actually organic carbon, as long as it is part of a larger organic molecule. I wouln't call two amine groups an "organic molecule", but...

Well, anyone who wants a more complete tutorial can do what I just did and Google the question:

"Is the carbonyl group considered 'organic carbon' if it is attached to two amine groups?"


Google insists that urea IS organic nitrogen, because the carbonyl group IS considered to be "fully organic, as it is part of a standard carbon-based molecular framework containing carbon-nitrogen and carbon-oxygen covalent bonds."

I won't copy it here now, but Google goes on with long with a multi-point section under the heading, "Why it Is Organic Carbon"

And I stand corrected. There is some chemistry that even I didn't fully know!
Page 27 of 28<<<25262728>





Join the debate Restoring Alkalinity to the Ocean:

Remember me

Related content
ThreadsRepliesLast post
The Slow Suffocation: How Fertilizer Runoff Creates Ocean Dead Zones5515-09-2026 19:17
Ocean ph.14731-08-2026 00:23
Geoengineering to Neutralize Ocean Acidification63525-08-2026 04:04
Ocean "acidification" once and for all?3208-07-2026 17:12
What the pHuck are bupHers, ocean acidipHication, and "pH"?507-05-2026 21:38
▲ Top of page
Public Poll
Who is leading the renewable energy race?

US

EU

China

Japan

India

Brazil

Other

Don't know


Thanks for supporting Climate-Debate.com.
Copyright © 2009-2020 Climate-Debate.com | About | Contact